The Cult of Confucius
Images of the Temple of Culture
Thomas A. Wilson
History and Asian Studies
Hamilton College
Version of this web page with Chinese characters
"Confucianism"
is a tradition that traces its beginnings to an educated elite called shi
of late antiquity that advised royal and regional feudal authorities during
the Zhou dynasty (1134-250 B.C.) on governing, which emphasized the importance
of virtuous rule through benevolence and proper conduct called ritual (li).
The most prominent figure of this educated elite was a man named Kong Qiu (551
to 479 B.C.), usually referred to as Master Kong (Kong-fu zi or Kongzi). In
the West, Kongzi is called Confucius, a name given him by Jesuit missionaries
in the sixteenth century. Kongzi was born in the Watch Tower (Queli) district
of Qufu, then the capital of the state of Lu of the Zhou kingdom. Kongzi was
the son of Shuliang He, who, according to some sources, was a descendant of
a prestigious lessor branch of a ducal lineage of the neighboring state of Song.
Kongzi was raised by his mother, Yan Zhengzai after his father died before he
was three.
During much of the imperial era of Chinese
history, the teachings and ritual practices of Confucianism occupied a privileged
status in the education and training of the men who served in the civil bureaucracy.
The precise ways in which the government expressed its preference for Confucianism
over competing schools, and the extent to which the state actually adhered to
Confucian doctrine, waxed and waned significantly during the course of the last
two thousand years. Although Confucius enjoyed a certain notoriety during his
own lifetime, it was not until the Han (206 B.C.-A.D. 220) that rulers began
to distinguish his teachings from those of other thinkers of the Zhou dynasty
by canonizing Confucianism as an officially favored teaching. The canonization
of Confucianism was a gradual and complex process that involved several different
types of official acts and proclamations that were not always consistently applied.
Perhaps the most signal act that effected this canonization was in 136 B.C.,
when the Han emperor Wu (r. 141-87 B.C.), acting on the advice of Dong Zhongshu
(ca. 179-104 B.C.), eliminated all court positions of canonical scholars called
Erudites who taught non-Confucian books, in effect establishing Confucianism
as the sole teaching of the imperial court. The court's privileging of the "Confucian
canon" became a critical part of the establishment of Confucianism as orthodoxy
in the Song (960-1279), with the emergence of the civil service examination
system as the most important means of appointment to positions in the bureaucracy.
Besides promoting a specific curriculum
in the examination halls, the court also articulated its understanding of Confucian
orthodoxy in a temple called the Kong temple, or the Temple of Culture. Here
the spirits of Kongzi, his disciples, and later canonical exegetes and "transmitters
of the Way" were enshrined and received sacrifices from representatives of the
emperor. The question of which Confucians of later ages would be enshrined in
the temple was controversial because it raised such issues as which commentaries
on the Confucian canon were acceptable and, by the Song, who was believed to
have received the true transmission of the Dao from Kongzi and Mengzi (Mencius).
A basic chronology of enshrinement shows the gradual
canonization of the Dao School version of the Confucian tradition, beginning
in the 1240s and particularly by Ming times.
|
The imperial court
promoted Confucianism by posthumously ennobling
Kongzi, first as duke and later as king. In addition to elevating
the figure of Kongzi to ever greater status, emperors also conferred hereditary
titles of nobility upon his descendants, initially as marquises, and by
Song times as dukes; a position Kongzi's descendants held until the 1940s.
Critical to this careful attention to the person of Kongzi as the embodiment
of the literati tradition was the state cult, which centered upon offering
sacrifices to Kongzi's spirit in the Kong
temple.
The sacrifices to the spirit of
Kongzi was part of a larger system of cult sacrifices to other gods and
spirits. This pantheon was headed by Heaven, to which only the emperor
offered sacrifices at an altar in the southern suburbs of the imperial
city, followed by Earth, which received sacrifices at an altar in the
northern suburbs.
|
An important event
in the canonizing process occurred in 195 B.C., when the founding emperor
of the Han dynasty, Han Gaozu (r. 206-195 B.C.), offered a Great Sacrifice
to the spirit of Confucius at his tomb in Qufu. As early as 241, sacrfices
to the spirits of Kongzi and his most prominent disciple, Yan Hui, were
offered in the Imperial University (Biyong). The picture on the left shows
the Imperial University in Beijing.
The first state temple devoted
to Kongzi was built in the Liu-Song, which ruled over south China from
420 to 479. The Confucius temple in Bejing was first built in 1302, and
was periodically repaired and rebuilt during the Ming (1368-1644) and
Qing (1644-1911) dynasties.
The temple
pictured on the right is the main hall, called the Hall of Great Completion
(Da cheng dian), of the Confucius Temple in Beijing, situated north east
of the Forbidden City. |
|
|
Beginning in the
Tang era, and particularly from Song times on, the state sacrifices to
Confucius in the capital became increasingly complex and closely regulated
by an official liturgy.
When the founder of the Southern
Song dynasty reestablished the capital in Lin'an (modern Hangzhou), an
imperial Confucius Temple was constructed (pictured on right). |
|
|
Kongzi's forty-eighth
generation descendant, Duke Kong Duanyou, followed the Song emperor, and
established the southern Kong lineage. By 1136 the Kongs settled in Quzhou,
Quzhou, Zhejiang, where they converted the local school temple into a
temple operated by Kongzi's descendants. Later a family temple honoring
Kongzi was established at a nearby lake. Around 1279, when the Southern
Song fell, this temple was destroyed by fire, and was not rebuilt until
1407. The present-day Quzhou Confucius temple (pictured on left) was moved
to its current location in 1520. |
According to most
accounts, a temple honoring Kongzi was built in his hometown in 478 B.C.
(17th year of Duke Ai of Lu), a year after his death. The sources suggest
that, since the early years of this temple, the spirits of Kongzi and
his disciples were represented with wall paintings and clay or wooden
statues. After years of court debate, it was decided in 1530 that these
spirits would not be represented by an iconic image of his likeness in
the imperial temples in the capital and other bureaucratic locations.
Opponents of iconic representations of Kongzi argued that such statues
copied Buddhist practices of temple worship and also tended to confuse
ritual ideas in ancestral sacrifice. They argued that imperial temples
were constructed to honor Kongzi's teachings, not just the spirit of the
flesh-and-blood man. The statues of Kongzi were removed from official
temples, but they remained in the temples operated by Kongzi's family
descendants, such as this statue of Kongzi in the Main Hall of Great Completion
of the Confucius Temple in Qufu. |
|
|
Evidence suggests
that as early as the eleventh century, Confucius temples had rooms to
pay sacrifices to Confucius' father Shuliang He, and in 1048, a hall was
built for this purpose. During the Yuan and Ming dynasties, ritualists
explored the connection between the family cult of Confucius' descendants
and the state cult of Confucius. When Shuliang He was posthumously honored
as Duke who Gave Birth to the Sage, shrines called the Shrine for the
Duke who Gave Birth to the Sage (Qisheng ci) were constructed to honor
Confucius' father. The shrine in Qufu pictured
here, was located immediately west of the Hall of Great Completion
in 1729. The Qufu shrine has fallen into disrepair and is currently undergoing
renovation; pictured here is the spirit statue of Shuliang He. |
Appendix A. "Confucianism"
The word "Confucianism" is a sixteenth-century Jesuit
conceit that purports to be a translation of a Chinese term. The most common
Chinese term for what Westerners call Confucianism, however, is more felicitously
rendered the "School of the Learned" (Ru jia). This educated Ru group
may have emerged within lower echelons of the aristocracy as early as the Shang
(1766-1027 B.C.), but it was apparently not understood as a distinctive school
of thought until relatively late. The three most prominent figures of the early
"School of the Learned" -- viz., Confucius (Kongzi), Mencius (Mengzi), and Xunzi
-- did not use it to name their tradition. They tended to speak, instead, of
the "Way of the Gentleman," not so much as a name for a philosophical tradition
than as a paragon of one who embodied virute in his conduct. In one of the earliest
histories of ancient Chinese philosophy, Sima Tan (d. 110 B.C.) names the "School
of the Learned" (or Ru jia) among other competing philosophical schools
in order to demonstrate that only the School of the Way and Potency (usually
referred to as Daoism) can encompass the strengths of all schools. The division
of the philosophical masters and their followers of the late Zhou into discrete
schools gained greater currency in the Han when Sima Tan's essay appeared in
the Historical Records, begun under his editorship and completed by his
son, Sima Qian. Even in Liu Xiang's (77-6 B.C.) more "Confucian" essay summarizing
seven schools of the late Zhou, one is struck by a concern that Kongzi's followers
had splintered rather than unified this school. Liu distinguishes among 103
schools of Kongzi's followers, divided according to different exegetical traditions
of the Confucian canon. Two other terms to refer to this school were coined
in Sima Qian's Historical Records: the "forest of the learned" (ru
lin), which became the standard term in most subsequent dynastic histories,
and Ru Learning, which, along with Ru jia, is commonly used today to
refer to Confucianism.
top of page
Appendix B. Posthumous noble titles conferred upon Kongzi
478 BCE (Jingwang 42): Duke Ai of Lu posthumously
confers title of Venerable Ni
1 CE (Western Han dynasty: Emperor Ping, 1st year/6th
month/10th day of the Yuanshi era): Exalted Ni Duke of Consummate Perfection
(Baocheng xuan Ni gong; Ni is a reference to Mt. Ni, southeast of Qufu, where
Kongzi's mother prayed for a child before he was born.)
492 (Latter Wei: Emperor Xiaowen, Taihe 16/2/21):
Sage of Culture Venerable Ni (Wensheng Nifu)
580 (Latter Zhou: Emperor Jing, Daxiang 2/3/1): Duke
of the state of Zou (Zouguo gong)
608 (Sui: Emperor Yang, forth year of the Daye era):
First Teacher Venerable Ni (Xianshi Nifu)
628 (Tang: Emperor Taizong, Zhenguan 2/12): First
Sage (Xiansheng)
637 (Tang: Emperor Taizong, Zhenguan 11): Exalted
and Venerable (Xuanfu)
657 (Tang Emperor Gaozong, Xianqing 2): restored to
First Sage (Xiansheng)
739 (Tang: Emperor Xuanzong, Kaiyuan 27/8/23): Exalted
King of Culture (Wenxuan wang)
1008 (Song: Emperor Zhenzong, Dazhong xiangfu 1/10/1):
Dark Sage and Exalted King of Culture (Xuansheng wenxuan wang)
1013 (Song: Emperor Zhenzong, Dazhong xiangfu 5/12/29):
Ultimate Sage and Exalted King of Culture (Zhisheng wenxuan wang)
1307 (Yuan: Emperor Wu, Dade 11/7/18): Great Completer,
Ultimate Sage and Exalted King of Culture (Dacheng zhisheng wenxuan wang)
1370 (Ming: Hongwu 3/6/6): noble titles for all gods
and spirits of the imperial pantheon eliminated (e.g., 5 sacred peaks, the
4 seas); only Kongzi's (and other figures enshrined in the Kong temple) title
is retained.
1530 (Jiajing emperor 9): Ultimate Sage, First
Teacher Master Kong (Zhisheng xianshi Kongzi)
1645 (Qing: Shunzhi emperor, 2/1/23): Great Completer,
Ultimate Sage, Exalted First Teacher of Culture (Dacheng zhisheng xianshi
Kongzi)
top of page
Appendix C. Chronology of Sacrifices to Kongzi and others in the Kongzi
Temple
169/170 CE (Lingdi jianning 2/3): beginning of regular
spring and autumn sacrifices to Kongzi in Qufu (based on liturgy of gods of
soils and grains)
271 (Jin dynasty, Emperor Wu, Taishi 7): the imperial
heir apparent personally offers sacrifices to Kongzi in the National University
445 (Liu-Song dynasty, Emperor Wen yuanjia 22): sacrifices
use six rows of dancers, three racks of hanging instruments, and the offerings
and vessels used appropriate for an upper lord
454 (Xiaowudi xiaojian 1/10/15): First temple built
outside of Lu, four years after the loss of Lu to Northern Wei
489 CE (Northern Wei dynasty, Emperor Xiaowen taihe
13/7/25): a Kongzi temple constructed in capital, first temple outside of
Qufu built in the north
630 (Tang dynasty, Taizong zhenÕguan 4): temples established
in prefectural and county state schools
Kongzi received the main offering as sage in the temple
of the Tang era and Yan Hui received offerings as correlate. For a short time
in the seventh century the Duke of Zhou was placed in the primary position
facing south as sage. In 657 the Duke of Zhou was removed and enshrined in
the temple for kings of the Zhou dynasty. Also ten of Kongzi's disciples were
enshrined as savants for their surpassing virtue in conduct, speech, governance,
culture and learning (see Analects 11.3).
647: enshrinement of twenty-two canonical commentators
and exegetes from the Zhou to the Han
720: seventy of Kongzi's disciples formally enshrined
739 (kaiyuan 27/8/23): Kongzi elevated to Exalted
King of Culture (previously known as Exalted Ni Duke of Consummate Perfection)
and his image seated facing south in temples in the two Directorates of Education
1084: Mengzi (Mencius) enshrined as a correlate with
Yan Hui; Xunzi (Hsun-tzu), Yang Xiong, and Han Yu enshrined as scholars
1104: Wang Anshi enshrined as correlate after Mengzi
(later demoted to scholar in 1126 and removed entirely in 1241)
1241: five Dao School (Daoxue) masters (Zhou Dunyi,
Zhang Zai, the Cheng brothers, Zhu Xi) enshrined
1267: Zeng Can (reputed author of the Great Learning)
and Kong Ji (reputed author of the Doctrine of the Mean) were promoted
to correlates marking the court's recognition of the canonical status of the
Four Books; enshrinement of Shao Yong, Sima Guang, and Lu Zuqian
1369 (Ming dynasty, Hongwu 2/): sacrifices in schools
suspended, they continue in Qufu
1372 (Hongwu 5): Sacrifices to Mengzi were suspended
but are resumed the following year
1382 (Hongwu 15): resumption of sacrifices to Kongzi
in the Imperial University
1477 (Chenghua 13/2/8): the number of sacrificial
vessels increased from ten to twelve and rows of dancers from six to eight,
effectively promoting Kongzi to status of emperor.
1496 (Hongzhi 9/2): the number of dancers was increased
to 72 as with the regulations for the son of Heaven
1530: enshrinement of five Song Confucians (including
Ouyang Xiu and Lu Xiangshan); removal of thirteen scholars and canonical
exegetes; demotion of seven others to local temples; elimination
of earlier ranking system based on posthumous titles (king, duke, marquis,
earl) and exclusive use of a hierarchy that divided the men enshrined into
sage, correlate, savant (housed in the main temple hall) and worthy and scholar
(housed in the eastern and western cloisters)
1531 (Jiajing 10): The Shrine for the Duke of Giving
Birth to the Sage (Kongzi's father)
1642: six Dao School masters (Zhou Dunyi, the Cheng
brothers, Zhang Zai, Shao Yong, and Zhu Xi) elevated to status of worthy
1712: Zhu Xi elevated to correlate
1724: restoration of several scholars removed in 1530
top of page
Appendix D. Versions of the Confucian Canon
Tang
Imperial Edition (653)
Correct Meaning of the Five Classics (Wujing zhengyi)
Ed. Kong Yingda, et al.
Mao Odes, Mao Heng (3rd c. B.C.) edition
Record of Rites, Zheng Xuan (127-200) edition
Book of Documents , Kong Anguo (156-174?) edition
Zhou Changes, Wang Bi (226-249) edition
Zuo Commentary on the Spring and Autumn Annals,
Du Yu (222-284) edition
Tang-Song
Nine Classics (Jiujing)
Mao Odes (Mao shi), Zheng Xuan (127-200) edition
Record of Rites (Li ji), Zheng Xuan (127-200)
edition
Rites of Zhou (Zhou li), Zheng Xuan (127-200)
edition
Ceremonial Rites (Yi li), Zheng Xuan (127-200)
edition
Ancient Text Book of Documents (Guwen shangshu),
Kong Anguo (156-174?) edition
Zhou Changes (Zhou yi), Wang Bi (226-249) edition
Zuo Commentary on the Spring and Autumn Annals
(Chunqiu Zuozhuan), Du Yu (222-284) edition
Gongyang Commentary on the Spring and Autumn Annals
(Chunqiu Gongyang zhuan), He Xiu (129-182) edition
Guliang Commentary on the Spring and Autumn Annals
(Chunqiu Guliang zhuan), Fan Ning (339-401) edition
Yuan
The Four Books and Five Classics
Analects (Lunyu zhangju jizhu), Zhu Xi (1130-1200)
edition
Mencius (Mengzi zhangju jizhu), Zhu Xi edition
Great Learning (Daxue zhangju jizhu), Zhu
Xi edition
Doctrine of the Mean (Zhongyong zhangju jizhu),
Zhu Xi edition
Basic Meaning of the Zhou Changes (Zhouyi benyi),
Cheng Yi and Zhu Xi edition
Collected Commentaries on the Book of Documents
(Shujing jizhuan), Cai Shen (1167-1230) edition
Collected Commentaries on the Odes (Shijing
jizhuan), Zhu Xi edition
Collected Explanations on the Record of Rites
(Liji jishuo), Chen Hao (fl. Yuan dynasty) edition
Three Commentaries on the Spring and Autumn Annals
(Chunqiu sanzhuan), Hu Anguo (1074-1138) edition
Ming
Imperial Edition (1415)
Great Collection of the Four Books and Five Classics
(Wujing sishu daquan)
Ed. Hu Guang, et al.
Four Books: Ni Shiyi edition
Change: Dong Zhenqing, Zhouyi huitong;
Hu Yigui, Zhouyi benyi; Hu Bingwen Zhouyi benyi tongshi
Odes: Zhu Xi, Shijing jizhuan
Documents: Chen Li, Shangshu jizuan;
Chen Shikai, Shu Caizhuan pangtong
Rites: Chen Hao, Liji jishuo
Spring and Autumn Annals: Wang Kekuan, Chunqiu
zuanshu; Li Lian, Chunqiu zhuzhuan huitong
Qing
Commentaries on the Thirteen Classics (1797)
Shisan jing zhushu
Ed. Ruan Yuan
Zhou Changes (Zhouyi), Wang Bi (226-249) ed.
Book of Documents (Shangshu zhengyi), Kong
Yingda (574-648) ed.
Mao Odes (Maoshi zhengyi), Kong Yingda) ed.
Record of Rites (Liji zhengyi), Kong Yingda
ed.
Rites of Zhou (Zhouli), Jia Gongyan (fl. 655)
ed.
Ceremonial Rites (Yili), Jia Gongyan (fl. 655)
ed.
Gongyang Commentary on the Spring and Autumn Annals
(Gongyang Zuozhuan), He Xiu (129-182) ed.
Guliang Commentary on the Spring and Autumn Annals
(Guliang Zuozhuan), Fan Ning (339-401) ed.
Zuo Commentary on the Spring and Autumn Annals
(Chunqiu Zuozhuan), Du Yu (222-284) ed.
Analects (Lunyu zhushu jiejing), He Yan (d.
249) ed.
Filial Piety (Xiaojing zhengyi), Xing Bing
(932-1010) ed.
Erya (Erya shu), Xing Bing ed.
Mencius (Mengzi zhushu jiejing), Sun Shi (962-1033)
ed.
back to beginning of "The
Confucian Canon"
Other websites on Confucianism and Chinese religions
and philosophy
Links to web sources on
Asian Philosophy and Religions maintained by the Institute of Chinese
Studies, University of Heidelberg
Benjamin Elman's Classical
Chinese Historiography for Chinese History: a bibliography of sources
on pre-twentieth century Chinese history
Joseph Adler's links for
Chinese religions and philosophy
Wesleyan
Neo-Confucian Etext Project: Chinese character versions of the Four
Books and major writings by Zhu Xi, Wang Yangming, and Liang Qichao
Links to complete e-text versions of the Thirteen
Classics and Twenty-five Dynastic Histories in Chinese called
Scripta Sinica maintained by Academia
Sinca, Taiwan. Chinese language software required
Links to complete Chinese-language (traditional characters)
e-text versions of the Thirteen Classics; pre-Qin philosophical writings;
Huang Zongxi's anthologies of Song, Yuan, and Ming Confucianism (Song-Yuan
xue'an, Ming ru xue'an); Tang poetry; Categorized Writings
of Zhu Xi; comprehensive mirrors of Chinese history (Zizhi tongjian
and Xu zizhi tongjian); Cao Xueqin's Dream of the Red Chamber;
Twenty-five Dynastic Histories
National Palace Museum in Taiwan
Steven A. Brown's Chinese
Philosophy Page
Stephen Angle's
Chinese Philosophical Etext Archive
Bryan W. Van Norden's Essential
Readings on Chinese Philosophy
and also Bryan W. Van Norden's selected list of Chinese
philosophy-related links
Bibliography
on Confucius and Confucianism
top of page
back to Thomas
Wilson's home page
back to Hamilton's Asian
Studies home page
back to Hamilton's History
home page