Editorial: Thanksgiving a good time to examine immigration policies : Stltoday FEAST LADUE NEWS ST. LOUIS' BEST BRIDAL SUBURBAN JOURNALS Not logged in Log In Register Subscribe My Account Edit Profile Logout stltoday.com ST. LOUIS' #1 SOURCE FOR NEWS PRINT EDITION E EDITION APPS St. Louis Post-Dispatch Home News Topics OBITS OPINION ILLINOIS ST. CHARLES CRIME POLITICS EDUCATION NATION FEATURED STORIES George Will: Sign code as a weapon NORFOLK, Va. • A drearily familiar dialectic is on display here: Government is behaving badly in order to silence protests of other bad behavi… Make it in the USA, especially Missouri When Apple, the world’s largest technology company, announced its plan to invest $100 million to transfer the manufacturing of some of its Mac… E.J. Dionne: Reagan is Obama's touchstone Fair or Foul: Speaker backs bond issue; redistricting gone wild Editorial: Ameren has tough sell in seeking new electric rate surcharge The 'old general' can manage his iPod ... but not his password Dana Milbank: Preaching to the choir Connect St. Louis and Chicago with true high-speed rail Business Topics DATABASES STOCKS STOCK QUOTES PRESS RELEASES SALARIES HOME VALUES COLUMNS First retail tenant coming to NorthSide? Not quite yet Even dollar store is waiting on the Supremes Real estate agents scammed, says BBB The Better Business Bureau says St. Louis real estate agents are being victimized in a "shakedown" run by operators of a "phony" complaint website. FEATURED Ralcorp CEO gets $1 million consulting deal Union membership drops by 51,000 in Missouri Roberts Tower project inches ahead St. Louis Outlet Mall expands hours of parental escort policy EU confirms A-B InBev's Bud trademark Sports Topics CARDINALS RAMS BLUES MIZZOU SLU COLLEGE GOLF FORUMS MORE SPORTS FEATURED Tipsheet: NCAA should declare moral bankruptcy Tipsheet empathizes with NCAA investigators. They are asked to “police” a badly flawed system, providing lip service to high-minded concepts l… Hockey Guy: Former Blues reunite in Motown Here's a familiar scenario: Carlo Colaiacovo suffers an injury and Kent Huskins steps in to replace him. Burwell: Where does Haith go to get his reputation back? Bernie: Day comes for fans' final farewell Gordon: NCAA earns ridicule for butchered probe Burwell: One-on-one with Wainwright Round Two: Strong start for Blues Bernie Bytes: NCAA comes off looking dirty High Schools Topics SPORTS SCHOOLS STATS SCHEDULES SCORES FEATURED Birschbach, Fox work OT to edge Lutheran South for tournament title AFFTON • As she stepped to the free-throw line with the game on the line Wednesday night, Erin Birschbach had an unpleasant flashback. No. 1 seed Hazelwood Central will take on No. 2 De Smet for tourney title TOWN AND COUNTRY • The Hazelwood Central boys basketball team hasn’t had much success offensively in its first two games at the Ameritime Clas… DuBourg rallies from eight-point deficit to stun O'Fallon Christian Big fourth quarter sparks Hazelwood East win over host Zumwalt North Fast start lifts Alton Marquette to 75-55 win over Madison Entertainment Topics CALENDAR MUSIC RESTAURANTS TV MOVIES CELEBRITIES ARTS & BOOKS COMICS & GAMES FEATURED Black history events aren't only about the distant past Here are some highlights of free events celebrating Black History Month. St. Louis comic Nikki Glaser is headed for MTV late-night Nikki Glaser of St. Louis makes her TV debut with pal Sara Schaefer on a new MTV talk show. MORE ENTERTAINMENT Taste test: How 5 new barbecue joints stack up Joyia Tapas brings Mediterranean flavors to the Grove Pitmasters gather to learn the barbecue trade Second thriller written by Lake Saint Louis cops set for release Feb. 5 Crown Candy Kitchen marks 100 years of delighting St. Louisans Lifestyles Topics HEALTH FOOD HOME & FASHION RELIGION STL MOMS & DADS PETS TRAVEL FEAST ST. LOUIS' BEST BRIDAL FEATURED Q&A: How to help child who is afraid of going to the doctor Make sure that your son is allowed to legally drive around at night at the age of 16. Valentine's Day packages: Lake of the Ozarks Today, we look at great romance packages from the resort in Indiana.  MORE LIFESTYLES Unmarried couple clash on living together Should you buy your child an e-reader? Valentine's Day packages: French Lick, Ind. Student needs help with anger management Weight is 'healthy' but not to her parents Suburban News Topics SUBURBAN JOURNALS METRO JOURNALS ILLINOIS JOURNALS ST. CHARLES JOURNALS FEATURED The farmer carried a badge Alwal "Al" Moore doesn't hesitate in stating his feelings about his life as a Sunset Hills resident. Student group aims to make Lindenwood more sustainable While Lindenwood University may be advancing with program and academic offerings, senior Zak Hafner noticed one area that needed improvement.  MORE Suburban Journals Fenton Mercantile finding new home in Faust Park Learning English a struggle for new immigrants Saeger coat drive helps fill a need in St. Charles County Laumeier Sculpture Park's charms brought bequest St. Charles County gun owners react to president's proposals Jobs Search Jobs Post Resume Employers Post a Job Work at the PD or SJ Salary Wizard Cost of Living Wizard Autos New Used Certified Research Service Dealers Specials Reviews Auto Print Ads Homes Place an Ad Search Homes Mortgage Guide Agent Directory Your Next Home What Did It Sell For Find n Save Newspaper Ads Circulars Today's Deal Coupons Get It Local Directory Special Sections P-D Store Classifieds Business Opportunities Notices Travel Tickets/Events Pets Estate Sales Garage/Yard Sales Bargain Box Merchandise Place An Ad Print Ads Home / News / Opinion / Columnists / The Platform Editorial: Thanksgiving a good time to examine immigration policies Print Email « Courtesy Missouri News Horizon\r ' );"> » 2012-11-21T06:00:00Z 2012-11-20T14:20:20Z Editorial: Thanksgiving a good time to examine immigration policies the Editorial Board stltoday.com November 21, 2012 6:00 am • the Editorial Board Loading… Let's secure our own borders first Securing our borders is a “war” that we can and must win. Who and what is coming into this great nation with impunity? Legal entrance, yes! Il… Read more If there’s a Butterball or some other mass-market turkey on your groaning board today, take a moment to think about Encarnación Bail Romero. The Guatemalan immigrant, who lives in southwest Missouri, until a few weeks ago worked at one of the turkey plants that helped this nation’s poultry industry produce about 248 million turkeys in 2011. Of those, 17.5 million came from plants in Missouri, making it the fourth-biggest turkey-producing state in the nation. Some of those turkeys made it to the market because Ms. Bail, and other workers like her, put in long hours of grim, stomach-churning work for little pay, all the while facing the threat of deportation. Ms. Bail is an undocumented immigrant. Her American-born son, Carlos, is a 6-year-old U.S. citizen. She hasn’t seen Carlos since the day in May 2007 when the Barry County chicken plant that employed Ms. Bail was raided by agents of the Immigration and Naturalization Service. Mother and son have never spent a Thanksgiving together. These days , Ms. Bail is allowed legally to stay in the U.S. as her appeal to regain custody of her son continues winding through the Missouri courts. It’s been a long battle with little hope. Carlos lives with another southwest Missouri family that adopted him while Ms. Bail was awaiting deportation to her home country. The Missouri Supreme Court was faced with the ultimate in judicial challenges when the case came before the court in 2010. There is no doubt Ms. Bail’s rights were denied when she was stuck in jail and a perhaps well-meaning conspiracy sought to provide Carlos a family by ending his mother’s parental rights. She didn’t speak English. She didn’t know what was happening to her. But by the time justice was sought, the judges were faced with taking the boy away from the family that had raised him for most of his life or returning him to a mother who spoke a different language and would take her son home to Guatemala. The court kicked the case back to the trial court, which this summer kept Carlos with his adoptive parents. Last week, lawyers for Ms. Bail asked the Missouri Supreme Court to take the case again. Today, all over this country, we offer thanks for the food on our tables and the families around us. We should pause, too, to consider the anguish wrought on other families by a broken immigration system. Ms. Bail is hardly alone. Thanksgiving is the ultimate immigration story. Most of what we know — or at least what we think we know — of the so-called first Thanksgiving we learned from a letter Edward Winslow wrote in December 1621 about a gathering between Pilgrims and about 90 members of the Wampanoag native tribe. The Pilgrims had endured some tough times, and the fall harvest that year was plentiful, so they celebrated. The Pilgrims, of course, were immigrants to a land where they were vastly outnumbered by people who had been here for centuries. In the mythological version of Thanksgiving we’ve devised today, built around turkey and pumpkin pie, those details get glossed over. “The Wampanoag, we sometimes forget, were the majority population,” Nancy Brennan, former director of the Plimoth Plantation museum, told The Christian Science Monitor in 2002. “In the 19th and 20th centuries, Thanksgiving was really a tool for Americanization amid the great influx of immigration. It was supposed to bind this diverse population into one union.” The nation’s most recent presidential election, which was quite divided along racial lines, suggests our union could use some more binding. Whether or notEncarnación Bail Romero ever sees her son again, she and Carlos are an example of everything that has gone wrong with U.S. immigration policy. The poultry industry is a more than $16 billion a year business, so when the huge corporations that dominate the field need workers, the government usually is willing to look the other way while those companies ignore the law to keep wages low. The 2007 raid on the Barry County plant took place in the walk-up to the 2008 presidential election. Then members of both parties were busy trying to demonstrate their tough anti-immigrant bona fides by screaming “build the border fence.” Raids like the one that ensnared Ms. Bail were common. Families were torn apart as parents were deported and their American-born children stayed behind. Companies, for the most part, got a pass. This Thanksgiving, the trend is the opposite direction. On June 15, in one of the most important acts in his first term, President Barack Obama signed an executive order allowing children of undocumented workers, who were brought to the country through no fault of their own, to delay their deportation. It mirrored the DREAM Act, which Congress refused to pass. It allowed those young people, most of whom have been educated in American schools, to continue to contribute to the only country they’ve ever called home. Since the president signed that order, more than 53,000 young immigrants have been able to put off deportation. Hundreds of thousands of others are in the pipeline, beginning the process to eventual citizenship. Republicans, reeling from Mr. Obama’s re-election, and his overwhelming popularity with Hispanic voters, are questioning their previous, harsh stances on issues of immigration. Their conversion should be a quick one. Which policy is more likely to rekindle thoughts of that first Thanksgiving: The one that divides families, and the nation, or the one that keeps parents and children at the same dinner table? America needs a bigger table. It needs to rekindle that simple spirit expressed in the Latin phrase that appears on the official Seal of the United States: E pluribus unum. Out of many, one. Tags Thanksgiving , Encarnacion Bail Romero , Pilgrim , Missouri , Wampanoag People , Illegal Immigration , Plymouth Colony , Missouri Supreme Court , Immigration And Naturalization Service , Dream Act , Guatemala , Barack Obama , Edward Winslow View Comments More The Platform stories George Will: Sign code as a weapon Make it in the USA, especially Missouri Refer: Abortion-rights advocates ignore reality E.J. Dionne: Reagan is Obama's touchstone Recommendations Sponsored Links Copyright 2013 stltoday.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. Advanced Search | Privacy | About Our Ads News News Web Search Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH St. Louis Coupons: Get fantastic deals — up to 80% off — sent to your e-mail. Sign up today! Choice St. Louis - Only $7 for $15 worth of food from Choice St. Louis! Newsletters | Subscribe to email newsletters Alerts | Sign up for news alerts Apps | Go mobile with the Post-Dispatch Facebook | Become a fan of STLtoday.com Twitter | Talk with us on Twitter Pinterest | STLtoday Pinterest RSS | Subscribe to our RSS feeds LATEST POSTS Fair or Foul: Speaker backs bond issue; redistricting gone wild Editorial: Ameren has tough sell in seeking new electric rate surcharge Editorial: Join hands, fans, on Stan the Man Span Editorial: It's quiet at the History Museum. Too quiet. Editorial: In president's call to action, an echo of Dr. King QUICK CLICKS Archives Calendar Columns & Blogs Comics Contests Databases Forums Galleries Horoscope Live chats Lottery Movie times Multimedia Obits Photo reprints Press releases RSS feeds Videos Traffic Weather DEALS, OFFERS AND EVENTS Current Trends Academy of Hair Design can help you with a FOIL COLOR! Classes start first Tuesday of every month! People with pyorrhea or periodontal disease have a 25% greater chance of having Coronary Heart Disease then those who have little or no gum disease or inflammation. Call today to schedule an appointment... Family owned and operated home care agency that is built on trust and compassion for our patients and their families. Visit our website www.compassionllc.com for more information. Availabilities at J & J Apartments Vandalia IL Renting for $410 or 30% of your income, whichever is higher. Need help getting a car, truck, van or SUV? We understand that bad things happen to good people. At Planet… Services Advertise Subscriber Services Email Newsletters Mobile E-Edition Archives Corrections Newspapers in Education Post-Dispatch Store Contact Us Get It © Copyright 2013, stltoday.com , 900 N. Tucker Blvd. St. Louis, MO | Terms of Service , Privacy Policy , and About our ads | Find Area Businesses Find Area Businesses St. Louis Apartments St. Louis Attorneys St. Louis Auto Dealers St. Louis Auto Parts St. Louis Auto Repair St. Louis Beauty Salons St. Louis Car Rental St. Louis Dentists St. Louis Doctors St. Louis Flowers St. Louis Hotels St. Louis Insurance St. Louis Loans St. Louis Mortgages St. Louis Movers St. Louis Pizza St. Louis Realtors St. Louis Restaurants St. Louis Storage St. Louis Tax Preparation St. Louis Travel More St. Louis… Featured × Logging in Login Signup Login here with a previously connected Facebook account. Login here with www.stltoday.com account: Email & Password Required! Email: Password: Remember me on this computer Forgot Password Please Wait… Login