We Need a Path to Citizenship for All Americans, Not Just Immigrants - Eric Liu - The Atlantic Skip Navigation The New Ways People Sicken and Die Do Not Strap a Jet Pack to Your Cat A Father Caring for His Offspring? Give the Man a Medal! Sponsor Content Big Data 101: What You Need to Know Politics Top Stories How to Win States and Disenfranchise People Why the GOP is Keeping Priebus How Boehner Tamed His Unruly Caucus The Party of John Calhoun Obama Pitched Gay Marriage to the Justices—Without Setting Foot in Court What Obama Forgot: Economic Growth Is the Only Way to Social Progress Business Top Stories Stop the Gloom About American Education Healthcare Spending: Not Just a Government Problem The Economics of Abortion The End of Cats: An Interview With the New Zealand Economist Calling to Eliminate All Kitties These Charts Tell You Exactly How and Where Apple Makes Money Right Now The 38 States That Have Slashed Higher Education Spending Sponsor Content Midsize Business Can Benefit from Cloud Computing Tech Top Stories The Never-Before-Told Story of the World's First Computer Art When We Blew Up Arizona to Simulate the Moon Do Not Try to Recreate This 16th-Century German Cat Bomb at Home At What Age Will You Stop Using Facebook? Maybe the End of the Women-in-Combat Ban Will Also Be the End of the Little, Pink Gun One Man's Defense of Java National Top Stories The Long Fight for Legal Marijuana Is Just Beginning Climate Change Could Wipe Out the Western Forests 'Stop and Frisk' Might Be Working—But Is It Racist? How Al Capone Got Away With Murder How America's Top Colleges Reflect (and Massively Distort) the Country's Racial Evolution At Supreme Court, Gay Marriage Foes Make Their Strongest Case Yet Sponsor Content Making Sense of Big Data to Fight Crime Global Top Stories How Obama Can [Verb] to His Way to [Noun]: A Foreign-Policy Mad Lib The Coming Rise of Afghan Militias Yes, Pakistanis Really Do Hate America's Killer Drones Anti-Trust Victory for China's LCD Makers, But Where is the Money? Ten Minutes to Help You Understand China's Environmental Emergency Just How Far Did the Israeli Electorate Move to the Center? The Democracy Report Social and political change around the world In China, Can Pollution Spur Media Transparency? Health Top Stories How the World Gets Sick and Dies Never Say Yes to a Nightcap Where Trees Are Sick, People Are Sick Study: People 'Highly' Enjoy Sex, Condom or No A Case for Shaming Obese People, Tastefully 'He Didn't Seem Crazy': Where Violence Meets Health Care Study of the Day Study: People 'Highly' Enjoy Sex, Condom or No Dr. Hamblin's Emporium of Medicinal Wonderments How Much Caffeine Before I End Up in the E.R.? Sexes Top Stories The Lonely Existence of Mel Feit, Men's Rights Advocate Servicemembers on the Women-in-Combat Ban, 20 Years Ago Dads Caring for Their Kids: It's Parenting, Not Babysitting Oh Those Feisty Dames, Benghazi Hearings Edition What Obama Doesn't Understand About Gender Inequality The End of Pro-Choice: Will 'No Labels' Really Help the Abortion Debate? Entertainment Top Stories Prodigy Envy Isn't New The '50 Shades' Film Will Be Bad, but Better Than the Book 'Lovelace': How Can a Film About Porn Be This Boring? Junior Seau's Family Is Suing the NFL Want Singers to Do the National Anthem Live? Don't Ridicule Flubs TV Networks' Blood-Splattered Race to Compete With 'The Walking Dead' Pop Theory Smart, fun / fun, smart The Psychology of Rooting for the Guy With the (Fake) Dead Girlfriend 1book140 TheAtlantic.com's reading club 1book140 January Discussion Schedule: 'Just Kids' Track of the Day Track of the Day: 'Love Songs In the Night' Magazine In This Month's Issue What’s Inside America’s Banks? The Dark Side of Anesthesia How Online Romance Is Threatening Monogamy The Ludicrous Charms of Downton Abbey How Google Made Mapping Personal Subscribe Renew Give a Gift Digital Editions ▶ Special Reports Video Photo Ebook Newsletters At What Age Will You Stop Using Facebook? Conor Friedersdorf Eric Liu - Eric Liu is co-author of The Gardens of Democracy and creator of the Citizen University , a conference on creative citizenship. He was a speechwriter and deputy domestic policy adviser for President Bill Clinton. All Posts Share « Previous Politics | Next Politics » Email Print Close We Need a Path to Citizenship for All Americans, Not Just Immigrants By Eric Liu Tweet Dec 14 2012, 7:45 AM ET Comment Comprehensive immigration reform is on the agenda for 2013, but it should be coupled with revamped civics education, national service, and more. New U.S. citizens take the Oath of Allegiance. (Lucas Jackson/Reuters) "A path to citizenship." Get used to that phrase: We're going to be hearing it a lot in 2013. Since the Republican Party got hard electoral evidence of its problem with Latino voters (and Asian voters , and basically voters of color and immigrants in general), some GOP leaders have become highly motivated to negotiate a deal for comprehensive immigration reform. A key part of any such deal will be whether and how undocumented immigrants can step out of the shadows and onto a much-discussed but ill-defined path to citizenship . The DREAMers -- young undocumented immigrants who, under the long-stalled DREAM Act would've been able to earn citizenship by going to the military or to college -- are the hopeful face and voice of reform advocacy. And because they embody an appealing case for reform, they may be able to lead a push that normalizes life for millions of other immigrants, documented or not. That would be great, for them and ultimately for the entire country. But for all the attention being paid to the creation of a path, we're neglecting the destination: citizenship itself. What is this thing that needs to be earned? What, besides a bundle of rights, does the status entail and require? What do longstanding citizens take for granted and what is asked of brand-new Americans? These kinds of questions aren't just for immigrants. Which is why we need to couple immigration reform with a citizenship agenda -- one that revitalizes the content and meaning of citizenship for everyone, and that connects the process of becoming American with the work of being American. A robust citizenship agenda should have several core components. First, fixing the franchise. Inconsistent registration standards, unclear processes for voting, epically long lines at the ballot -- the stories are still fresh, and with the election behind us there's a narrow window for a national push to reform registration and voting procedures and to rationalize the rules of democratic participation. Second, redoubled support for civic education. The rationale for having compulsory public schooling at all, as Justice Sandra Day O'Connor often points out, is to make citizens. But today, in an age of reading and math testing, civics courses have atrophied or disappeared altogether in many of our schools. Civic education needs more funding, more teachers, more creativity in the curriculum, and more champions in national politics. Third, a redoubled emphasis on the importance of Americanization. Yes, that word conjures up images of 19th-century busybodies trying to Anglicize Italians, Jews, and other non-WASPs. But properly understood, Americanization  -- ensuring that a diverse new generation buys into the content of our national creed  -- remains a vital, necessary endeavor. We need to recommit to it in an inclusive 21st-century way -- in classrooms and communities, and through new civic rituals that make something from our diversity. Fourth, a revitalized national-service movement that amplifies existing programs for young people like AmeriCorps but also does much more to activate Americans of every age to serve. The Aspen Institute has launched the Franklin Project to push national service onto the elite political and cultural agenda. What's needed is a deeply local counterpart. Returning veterans can be a particular focus: Plugging them into the civic life of their hometowns is a win-win. And fifth, using government in savvy and catalytic ways to foster orders of magnitude more citizen-driven social innovation. The Obama Administration has already started doing this, as have some congressional Republicans . One approach could be to seed a public-private "C Prize" in the spirit of the X Prize: a set of sizable challenge awards that stimulate creative forms of citizen problem-solving at the local level. Meanwhile, there is now a generation of social entrepreneurs whose nonprofit ventures like City Year or the Harlem Children's Zone have made positive civic impact. Let's disseminate that know-how to more people by creating a network of civic "extension agents" akin to those in agricultural states who spread effective methods of planting and farming. A great citizenship agenda, like an optimal immigration-reform deal, should appeal to both right and left. Because such an agenda will encourage people to govern themselves more actively rather than relying on the state as the solution of first resort, conservatives will appreciate it. Because it connects the challenges and experiences of immigrant communities to the core of national life, progressives will value it. Moreover, when the so-called fiscal cliff and debt-ceiling fights have finally ended, either we will need a period of serious reconciliation or we will be on a collective high about a new politics of compromise. Either way, the time will be right to promote a common citizenship agenda. The time is right in a bigger sense too. The face and voice of America are changing more rapidly than our national self-story and institutions. Globalization, migration, technology, and the speed of media -- these forces are centrifugal. We need a new American centripetal force, a movement of politics and culture and civic religion. Citizenship in a democracy can't be just a matter of law; it has to be way of life. So yes, let's get more immigrants on the path to citizenship -- then let's make sure the destination is more than an afterthought. Share Email Print Presented by More at The Atlantic Servicemembers on the Women-in-Combat Ban, 20 Years Ago The 38 States That Have Slashed Higher Education Spending Racial Trends at America's Top Colleges Separating Fact From Balderdash in a Letter Recommending John Brennan The Never-Before-Told Story of the World's First Computer Art Join the Discussion After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register. Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus. blog comments powered by Disqus Eric Liu's Archive Recent Posts All Entries Current Week Previous Week By Source All Sources Magazine Articles Blog Articles By Date Writers Derek Thompson The End of Cats: An Interview With the New… 10:25 AM ET James Fallows Ten Minutes to Help You Understand China's… 9:26 AM ET Jeffrey Goldberg Just How Far Did the Israeli Electorate Move to… 9:00 AM ET Ta-Nehisi Coates The Party of John Calhoun Jan 23, 2013 Alexis C. Madrigal Do Not Try to Recreate This 16th-Century German… Jan 23, 2013 Garance Franke-Ruta A Fittingly American Ceremony, Without Much Pomp Jan 21, 2013 Steve Clemons Officials: Chuck Hagel Was a 'Gift From God' for… Jan 6, 2013 The Biggest Story in Photos Chicago's Freezing Fire Jan 24, 2013 Subscribe Now SAVE 65%! 10 issues JUST $2.45 PER COPY STATE AK AL AR AZ CA CO CT DC DE FL GA HI IA ID IL IN KS KY LA MA MD ME MI MN MO MS MT NC ND NE NH NJ NM NV NY OH OK OR PA RI SC SD TN TX UT VA VT WA WI WV WY YT Subscribe Facebook Newsletters Sign up to receive our free newsletters This Week on TheAtlantic.com ( sample ) This Month in The Atlantic ( sample ) Today's Top Stories on The Atlantic.com ( sample ) New from In Focus: ( sample ) 5 Best Columns from The Atlantic Wire ( sample ) Daily Newsletter from The Atlantic Cities ( sample ) I want to receive updates from our partners and sponsors Most Popular 1 There's More to Life Than Being Happy 2 The End of Cats: An Interview With the New Zealand Economist Calling to Eliminate All Kitties 3 How to Win States and Disenfranchise People: The GOP's Electoral-Vote Plan 4 The Never-Before-Told Story of the World's First Computer Art (It's a Sexy Dame) 5 The Long Slog to Legalizing Marijuana in the U.S. Is Just Beginning 6 The Lonely Existence of Mel Feit, Men's Rights Advocate 7 The European Southern Observatory 8 How America's Top Colleges Reflect (and Massively Distort) the Country's Racial Evolution 9 Chicago's Freezing Fire 10 The '50 Shades of Grey' Film Will Be Better Than the Book (But Still Bad) ATLANTIC MEDIA Atlantic Wire Lena Dunham vs. Rihanna Why the End of the Apple Bubble Is Bad for Everyone Obama's New Nominations Are Meant to Scare Wall Street More from Atlantic Wire Atlantic Cities Should Manhattan Rebuild This Ruined Subway Station? Class-Divided Cities: New York Edition Urban Planning's Role in Making India Safer for Women More from Atlantic Cities Quartz How the Post Office can save America: A Quartz data essay India’s boom of literary festivals is all pomp, no profits Ever-growing numbers of Spain’s lost generation are paying the price of austerity More from Quartz National Journal Is the GOP Moving to the Center? Or Just Getting Sane? Obama Signals Tougher Approach on Wall Street with SEC Pick After Taking on Terrorists, Can Mary Jo White Handle Tycoons? More from National Journal Elsewhere on the web Sponsored Links Follow The Atlantic App store Facebook Twitter Linkedin Google Plus Tumblr RSS E-Newsletters Today's Top Stories This Week This Month New at In Focus Atlantic Cities 5 Best Columns Information FAQ Subscribe Help Masthead Store Merchandise Jobs Privacy Site Map Terms and Conditions Advertise Press Contact Us Special Reports Atlantic Scene Ebook Events Atlantic Media Company Subscribe Get 10 issues a year and save 65% off the cover price STATE AK AL AR AZ CA CO CT DC DE FL GA HI IA ID IL IN KS KY LA MA MD ME MI MN MO MS MT NC ND NE NH NJ NM NV NY OH OK OR PA RI SC SD TN TX UT VA VT WA WI WV WY YT Next ► Copyright © 2013 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All Rights Reserved. CDN powered by Edgecast Networks. Insights powered by Parsely . Powered by the Parse.ly Publisher Platform (P3).