#SWTS.news.feed DCSIMG Dynamic Dart Advertisement The Scotsman iPad app IFRAME: http://www2.jpscotland.co.uk/scotsman/iFrameAds/iFrameHeader.html Please upgrade your browser * News + Scottish news o Top stories o Edinburgh, East & Fife o Glasgow & West o North East o Tayside & Central o Inverness & Highlands o South of Scotland + UK + International + Politics o Top stories o Scottish independence + Opinion + Holyrood live + Transport + Pictures + Education + Environment + Health + Arts + Celebrity + Sci-Tech + Gaelic + Odd + Cartoon + Leaders + Obituaries + Letters + Public Notices * Sport + Football o Top Football Stories o SPL o SFL Division One o SFL Division Two o SFL Division Three o Scottish Cup o League Cup o English o International o European + Rugby o Top Rugby Stories o International o Club rugby + Golf + Tennis + Horse Racing + Snooker + Cricket + Boxing + Commonwealth Games + Athletics + Motorsport + Other sports + Transfer Talk * Business + Banking + Insurance + Economics + Energy and Utilities + Retail + Food, Drink and Agriculture + Transport + Industry + Technology + Management + Market Reports + Media and Leisure + Interviews + Opinion + Personal Finance + Special reports + Business Briefing + Business Player * Lifestyle + Features + Motoring o Top stories o Reviews + Food and Drink o Features o Restaurant reviews o Wine o Recipes o Whisky + Outdoors o Features o Walk of the Week o Shooting & Fishing o Roger Cox + Travel + Music o News and features o Album reviews o Gig reviews o Classical reviews o Radar music blog + Books o Features o Book reviews + Comedy + Film + Arts blog + TV and Radio + Performing Arts o Theatre reviews o Dance reviews + Visual Arts + Fashion + Homes and Gardens + Health + Technology o Gadget reviews o Gaming reviews + Heritage + Pictures + Deal Monster * eMarket + Holidays & Offers + Events & Training + Promotions o Supplements + Subscriptions + About Us o Our Products o Advertise With Us o Contact Us + Competitions + Bingo + JP Offers + Announcements o In Memoriam o Birthdays o Weddings o Anniversaries o Special Day Notices o Best Wishes + Jobs + Property News + Buy A Photo + Apprenticeships + Reader Travel + Motors * The Scotsman + Scotland + UK + International + Politics + Transport + Education + Health + Environment + Gaelic + Legal + Obituaries + Opinion o Comment o Leader comment o Letters o Cartoon + Games o Crosswords o Chess & Bridge + Sport o Football o Rugby o Golf o Tennis o Other sports + Sport comment + Business + Business comment + Personal Finance + Features + Scotsman Magazine o Features o Food & Drink o Outdoors o Travel + Books o Reviews and news o Scotland Street + The Arts o Features o Alistair Harkness o Fiona Shepherd o Joyce McMillan o Duncan Macmillan o Kenneth Walton o Jim Gilchrist o Susan Mansfield o Arts Blog + Images of Scotland * Scotland on Sunday + Scotland + UK + Politics + International + News analysis + Sport o Football o Rugby o Golf o Other sports + Sport columnists o Tom English o John Huggan o Aidan Smith + Business + Business opinion + Money + Webchats + Opinion o Comment o Leaders o Andrew Wilson o Euan McColm o Dani Garavelli o Gerald Warner o Chitra Ramaswamy o Louisa Pearson o Ruth Walker o Letters + Spectrum o Features o Lifestyle o Relationships o Food & Drink o Fashion o Travel + The Week o Main features o Books o Film o Music o Art o TV reviews o Peter Ross o Claire Black o Fordyce Maxwell o Andrew Eaton-Lewis + At Home o Features o Lynn O'Rourke o Homes o Gardens * Edinburgh Evening News + Latest news + Edinburgh o Top Stories o Central Edinburgh o North Edinburgh o South Edinburgh o East Edinburgh o West Edinburgh o Around the Capital + East Lothian + Midlothian + West Lothian + Politics + Education + Health + Transport + Crossword + Sport + Football o Top stories o Hearts o Hibs o Livingston o Local football + Rugby o Top Rugby Stories o Edinburgh Rugby o Club rugby o Int'l rugby + Golf + Athletics + Ice hockey + Speedway + Other Sport + Features o Fashion o Nostalgia o Food & Drink o The Weekender + The Guide o Music o Theatre o Comedy o Film o Clubbing + Caption Competition + Obituaries + Readers' Queries + Opinion o Leader comment o Analysis o Margo MacDonald o Brian Monteith o Martin Hannan o Gina Davidson o Ian Swanson o Helen Martin o Susan Morrison o John Gibson o Talk of the Town o Letters o Cartoon Sponsored by Rock Roll Search site ____________________ Search Button Monday 21 January 2013 Log in Register Welcome Change profile Log out Welcome Log out * Find it * Jobs * Property * Motors * Announcements * You are here * News SWTS.news.image.e Stephen McGinty: The case for US and them Picture: Warner Brothers Picture: Warner Brothers By STEPHEN MCGINTY Published on Saturday 29 September 2012 00:00 THERE’S a long history of the guardians of the English language battling bravely against creeping Americanisms, but the reality is that it’s a two-way process, writes Stephen McGinty “Cops?” My wife’s lip curled up into a smug little sneer. “Where do you think we are? Boston.” I could, at that moment, have pointed out that Glasgow does share a grid system of streets which makes it a convenient stand-in for the average American city, but figure this would only delay chastisement for a linguistic dalliance with my current “Americanism” of choice. For I’m shamed to admit that I have an unconscious habit of referring to the police by an American slang. Still, it is preferable to referring to them as the police “service” which has replaced the word “force”, probably on the grounds that it sounds friendlier. However, to my mind, a service is optional, you can either choose to make use of a service or not, and yet the role of the police is to enforce the law, obedience to which is not at all optional. Why I refer to them as “cops” is the same reason that I say, and typing this makes me cringe a little, that I will “touch base” with someone or agree that an idea “came out of left field”. Now I’m reasonably comfortable with the use of American baseball terms, for in my youth I played short stop for the Dalriada Demons (no smirking at the back, please) which was set up in Lanarkshire once the locals discovered baseball bats had an alternative use to the one to which they were usually, and vigorously, applied. In fact, I was chosen to represent my country against England, but the promise of an international (baseball) cap floated away with the mound when the game was rained off. I don’t mind certain Americanisms, those words and phrases that wheedle their way into everyday usage such as “talented” and “reliable”. You weren’t aware that both words originally hailed from across the Atlantic? OK. Neither did I before I researched this column, but, apparently William Coleridge cast his disdain on “talented” which he described as a barbarous word in 1832, but Gladstone didn’t seem to mind as he was using it in speeches a few years later. The letter writers to the Times, like their counterparts in corresponding to The Scotsman, have always sought to protect the English language, with one writing in 1857 to describe the new American word “reliable” as vile. It was a Scot who first coined the term “Americanism”. John Witherspoon, the president of Princeton College, first used it in an article published in the Pennsylvania Journal, in which he wrote: “The first class I call Americanisms, by which I understand a use of phrases or terms, or a construction of sentences, even among persons of rank and education, different from the use of the same terms or phrases or construction of similar sentences in Great Britain. The word Americanism, which I have coined for the purpose, is exactly similar in its formation and signification to the word Scotticism.” When the Founding Fathers set sail for America, the English they spoke upon landing would have been identical to that spoken in Plymouth, but over the decades and centuries subtle differences have emerged. They were first codified by Noah Webster, a linguist from Connecticut who familiarised himself with 26 languages, and wrote An American Dictionary of English Language in 1828. It was he who struck out the “u” from colour and the extra “l” from travelled and sneakily swopped a “c” for an “s” in defence. But they wouldn’t let him have his way with women, which he wished to spell “wimmen”. If the appearance of American words caused mild consternation to poets and letter writers to the Times in the early 19th century, it was probably just as well that they were long dead when the marshalled forces of the American English began to lay siege to our nation during our darkest hour. When movies (yes, that could be described as an Americanism, but is also, I would argue, accurate when used to describe an American film) developed sound and recorded dialogue in the 1930s American words and phrases poured from the cinema screen into British ears. Then, when hundreds of thousands of American GIs descended into English towns and villages the frottage between words was heated. There are those who cannot stand “Americanisms”. A few years ago the BBC encouraged listeners to write in with their foulest examples which included “bi-weekly” instead of fortnightly (surely bi-weekly should be used for any occurrence whose frequency is twice a week?); “eaterie”, “hike” as in to raise prices, “going forward” and “you do the math” which, to my mind, is particularly callous, bullying the letter ‘s’ away from his friends m, a, t and little h. Others were enraged by the insertion of redundant words, as in “I got it for free” or the counter-intuitive “I could care less”, which in its literal meaning indicates that you do care a reasonable amount but that this could be lowered, when what the person actually meant to say is: “I couldn’t care less.” Clearly British people do not wish to have “an issue” but prefer to have “a problem” and then we come to aural and linguistic atrocities such as “my bad” for “my fault”. The utterances of a repentant three-year-old should never form the basis of an adult’s vocabulary. (A small aside which indicates that we, in Britain, are equally capable of mugging the English language and leaving it stunned in a ditch: since when did the cloying, saccharine phrase “little ones” become synonymous with “children” or “toddlers”? And, please, can anyone who uses it go immediately to the “naughty step”.) Yet if I have a current pet hate among “Americanisms” it is the phrase “reaching out”. I recently sent an e-mail to a company in Los Angeles who said they could not be of assistance but thanked me for “reaching out”. Have you ever heard a more belittling collision of two words? To ask, in which both parties are on equal footing, has been usurped by a phrase which elevates one and reduces the other. I was the pitiful party drowning in a quicksand of my own ignorance but bravely “reaching out” as if towards the security of a branch or vine. I accept, however, that there is nothing to be done about “Americanisms” other than to make a personal choice about which ones, if any, you are prepared to admit into your everyday vocabulary. Personally, I’m happy to take the lift over the elevator, but would prefer to live in an apartment rather than a flat. When it comes to my car, which is an American Chrysler, I’ll still remain British and swerve around the gas tank, hood and trunk, in favour of petrol, bonnet and boot. The English language will continue to evolve and it is impossible to build a fence around what has, over centuries, blended German, French, Dutch and Latin into its own rich stew of letters. It is, however, important to remember that words and phrases, like little linguistic cargo vessels, are constantly bobbing back and forth across the Atlantic. This week Kory Stamper, associate editor for Merriam-Webster, whose dictionaries are used by the majority of American publishers, said more words were finding their way into American vocabulary. So while we shake our heads over people who use the term “the fall” instead of “autumn”, our opposite number, who happens in this case to be Geoffrey Nunberg, a linguist at Berkeley, is curling his lip with disdain as a friend says that something is “spot on”. As he said this week: “ ‘will do’ – I hear that from Americans [as well]. That should be put into quarantine.” There is even a blog, run by Ben Yagoda, professor of English at the University of Delaware, which tracks the appearance of British words in American English and highlights words and phrases such as “cheeky”, “sell by date” and “the long game”, which, according to the BBC, was used by Barack Obama in a recent speech and is derived from the British card game, whist. Among the most prominent figures leading the fight back for British English is JK Rowling who bestowed upon that great nation the word “ginger” as a means to describe a redhead. While many words in her first Harry Potter novel were given an American substitute, a few “snuck” through including the quintessentially British word “snog”. Hopefully her latest book, The Casual Vacancy, with its portrait of an English parish council, will help redress the balance. * * Email to a friend Email to a friend * Print this page Print this page Top stories * Creative Scotland to hold talks with arts groups * Scotland a ‘dynamic world laboratory’ for independence debates, former US ambassador says * Lynda Spence murder trial hears victim was tortured * Doctor named as fourth Glencoe avalanche victim * Scot amongst confirmed dead at Algerian gas plant News * Scottish news * UK * International * Politics * Opinion * Holyrood live * Transport * Pictures * Education * Environment * Health * Arts * Celebrity * Sci-Tech * Gaelic * Odd * Cartoon * Leaders * Obituaries * Letters * Public Notices Dynamic Dart Advertisement * Popular * Most comments * Most shared * Survivor’s grief for friends swept away by Glencoe avalanche * Tram contractors go off the rails with latest blunder * No in-out option as Tories prepare for Cameron’s crucial speech on EU * Glencoe avalanche victims ‘spent all their free time in the mountains’ * Scottish independence: Spending on defence ‘sells Scots short’ by £1.9bn * Rangers repeat ticket stance for Scottish Cup tie against Dundee United * Scottish independence: Constitution ‘like framing picture that hasn’t been painted’ * Neil Lennon admits Gary Hooper ‘has his price’ and prepares for more offers * ‘Toughened up’ Rangers coping with Third Division, says Ally McCoist * Scottish independence: Unionist parties will beat SNP with devo message, says Tory * Wanted: New Scottish Government PR guru after Andrew Baird jumps ship * Exhibition reviews: Derek Clarke RSA | William Gillies | John Bellany * Tram contractors go off the rails with latest blunder * Scottish independence: Spending on defence ‘sells Scots short’ by £1.9bn * It’s ‘Blue Monday’, the worst day of the year Find It Search for: (Plumber, Taxi, McDonalds...) ____________________ Where? (town, county etc.) ____________________ "Business owner? - Claim your business and Advertise with us" Search In association with qype logo Looking for... Featured advertisers Jobs Search for a job Keywords: ____________________ (Submit) Search Motors Search for a car Make Model [Any Model] Price from [£0......] Price to [£11,000.] (Submit) Search Property Search for a house (_) Buy (_) Rent Bedrooms [1.] Price from [£50,000......] Price from [£200...] Price to [£150,000..] Price to [£1,000...] (Submit) Search Dynamic Dart Advertisement Weather for Edinburgh Monday 21 January 2013 5 day forecast Today Light snow showers Light snow showers Temperature: 0 C to 2 C Wind Speed: 24 mph Wind direction: East Tomorrow Light snow showers Light snow showers Temperature: -2 C to 2 C Wind Speed: 13 mph Wind direction: East Special Features * Las Vegas- no longer the gambling capital of the world? * How to Spend £100 in the Canary Islands Home * Home * Contact us * Register * Topics A-Z Services & Offers * Jobs * Motors * Property * Local Business * Family Announcements * Special Offers * Competitions * Buy a Photo * Shop * Cashback 4 shopping * Dating * Save on your energy bills * Deal Monster * Advertise With Us * Special Features * Contact us * Help * Accessibility * Terms and Conditions * Disclaimer * Cookies Policy * Switch to Mobile Site All rights reserved © Johnston Publishing Ltd. Press Complaints Commission This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here. If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here. Scotsman.com provides news, events and sport features from the Edinburgh area. For the best up to date information relating to Edinburgh and the surrounding areas visit us at Scotsman.com regularly or bookmark this page. For you to enjoy all the features of this website Scotsman.com requires permission to use cookies. [BUTTON] Allow Cookies Find Out More ▼ * What is a Cookie? * What is a Flash Cookie? * Can I opt out of receiving Cookies? * About our Cookies * Cookies are small data files which are sent to your browser (Internet Explorer, Firefox, Chrome etc) from a website you visit. They are stored on your electronic device. * This is a type of cookie which is collected by Adobe Flash media player (it is also called a Local Shared Object) - a piece of software you may already have on your electronic device to help you watch online videos and listen to podcasts. * Yes there are a number of options available, you can set your browser either to reject all cookies, to allow only "trusted" sites to set them, or to only accept them from the site you are currently on. However, please note - if you block/delete all cookies, some features of our websites, such as remembering your login details, or the site branding for your local newspaper may not function as a result. * The types of cookies we, our ad network and technology partners use are listed below: + Revenue Science ► A tool used by some of our advertisers to target adverts to you based on pages you have visited in the past. To opt out of this type of targeting you can visit the 'Your Online Choices' website by clicking here. + Google Ads ► Our sites contain advertising from Google; these use cookies to ensure you get adverts relevant to you. You can tailor the type of ads you receive by visiting here or to opt out of this type of targeting you can visit the 'Your Online Choices' website by clicking here. + Webtrends / Google Analytics ► This is used to help us identify unique visitors to our websites. This data is anonymous and we cannot use this to uniquely identify individuals and their usage of the sites. + Dart for Publishers ► This comes from our ad serving technology and is used to track how many times you have seen a particular ad on our sites, so that you don't just see one advert but an even spread. This information is not used by us for any other type of audience recording or monitoring. + ComScore ► ComScore monitor and externally verify our site traffic data for use within the advertising industry. Any data collected is anonymous statistical data and cannot be traced back to an individual. + Local Targeting ► Our Classified websites (Photos, Motors, Jobs and Property Today) use cookies to ensure you get the correct local newspaper branding and content when you visit them. These cookies store no personally identifiable information. + Grapeshot ► We use Grapeshot as a contextual targeting technology, allowing us to create custom groups of stories outside out of our usual site navigation. Grapeshot stores the categories of story you have been exposed to. Their privacy policy and opt out option can be accessed here. + Subscriptions Online ► Our partner for Newspaper subscriptions online stores data from the forms you complete in these to increase the usability of the site and enhance user experience. + Add This ► Add This provides the social networking widget found in many of our pages. This widget gives you the tools to bookmark our websites, blog, share, tweet and email our content to a friend. + 3rd Party Cookies ► We use Advertising agencies to provide us with some of the advertising on our websites. These include (but are not limited to) Specific Media, The Rubicon Project, AdJug, AdConion, Context Web. Please click on the provider name to visit their opt-out page. Close Send to a friend Your Friend's Name ____________________ Please enter a username Your Friend's e-mail Address ____________________ Please enter an email address Your Name ____________________ Please enter your username Your e-mail Address ____________________ Please enter your email address Your message ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ Please enter a message (true) Send Close Report Your reason for report ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ Please enter a message (true) Submit Close Weather for Edinburgh Tuesday 22 January 2013 Light snow showers Light snow showers Temperature: -2 C to 2 C Wind Speed: 13 mph Wind direction: East Wednesday 23 January 2013 Sunny spells Sunny spells Temperature: -3 C to 1 C Wind Speed: 6 mph Wind direction: East Thursday 24 January 2013 Cloudy Cloudy Temperature: -3 C to 0 C Wind Speed: 5 mph Wind direction: West Friday 25 January 2013 Cloudy Cloudy Temperature: 2 C to 4 C Wind Speed: 13 mph Wind direction: South west Saturday 26 January 2013 Light rain Light rain Temperature: 4 C to 7 C Wind Speed: 20 mph Wind direction: South