Warning over 'Americanisation' of UK universities | Education | Education Guardian Turn autoplay off Turn autoplay on Please activate cookies in order to turn autoplay off Jump to content [s] Jump to site navigation [0] Jump to search [4] Terms and conditions [8] Edition: UK US Sign in Mobile Your profile Your details Your comments Your clippings Your lists Sign out Mobile About us About us Contact us Press office Guardian Print Centre Guardian readers' editor Observer readers' editor Terms of service Privacy policy Advertising guide Digital archive Digital edition Guardian Weekly Buy Guardian and Observer photos Today's paper The Guardian G2 features Comment and debate Editorials, letters and corrections Obituaries Other lives Sport Subscribe Subscribe Subscribe to the Guardian iPhone app iPad edition Kindle Extra Guardian Weekly Digital edition All our services The Guardian Education User comments News Sport Comment Culture Business Money Life & style Travel Environment Tech TV Video Dating Offers Jobs News Education Higher education Warning over 'Americanisation' of UK universities Share Tweet this Email Anthea Lipsett Education Guardian , Wednesday 6 June 2007 12.18 BST The government must hold a debate on the future of higher education in the UK before it moves any further towards an Americanised elitist system, the House of Lords has heard. Addressing the National Conference of University Professors in the House of Lords last night, Lady Margaret Sharp, the Liberal Democrats education spokesperson, said the government's moves to raise the cap on student fees and effectively create an elitist system were "interesting". But she bemoaned the government "pushing us in this direction without any debate". Lady Sharp warned that privatising the UK HE sector along the lines of the US higher education model would not mean an end to the public funding of universities, and the system would inevitably be hierarchical. "But it's not just ivy league universities in the US. There are vast numbers of universities that range in size and quality." The "willy nilly" route the government is pushing would increase diversity but the system would inevitably become hierarchical, she said. "This has happened in America. If we look around the world in many senses the best system is the American one. They do fantastic research and have a flexible system for all students that meets the needs of the individual much better than the UK. The downside of it is that at the top end it's marvellous but we should be aware of the fact that only 2% of people from lower socioeconomic backgrounds go to Harvard and Yale. Oxford and Cambridge are models by ivy league standards." Baroness Sharp said there was pressure to lift the cap on student top up fees to allow universities to charge "what they will". "That's fine but I think we should be aware of the route that this is taking British universities. In effect, we are moving into the American model of universities. If we take the cap off we will have some universities charging £15,000 or more a year and hopefully they will be able to raise funds for other (less well-off) students. "US states subsidise colleges and if we move down this model we will still have the state paying for colleges," she said. "We may find ourselves confronted by the worst of all systems if the government doesn't keep its nit-picking fingers out. The great danger is we will get this [privatised] elitist model and the government will still be telling us what we should be doing. It's essential that the government changes its stance and trusts academics to get on with it. "We need to discuss and be clearer about where we are going," she said. "It seems to me that the key issue that dominates what's happening is this issue of globalisation and as a country we can no longer live by brawn and have to live by brain." Print this Share Contact us Send to a friend Sender's name Recipient's email address Your IP address will be logged Share Short link for this page: http://gu.com/p/xja6q StumbleUpon reddit Tumblr Digg LinkedIn Google Bookmarks del.icio.us livejournal Facebook Twitter Contact us Contact the Education editor education@guardian.co.uk Report errors or inaccuracies: userhelp@guardian.co.uk Letters for publication should be sent to: letters@guardian.co.uk If you need help using the site: userhelp@guardian.co.uk Call the main Guardian and Observer switchboard: +44 (0)20 3353 2000 Advertising guide License/buy our content Article history About this article Warning over 'Americanisation' of UK universities This article was published on guardian.co.uk at 12.18 BST on Wednesday 6 June 2007 . Education Higher education UK news Share Tweet this Email We Own The Weekend Celebrate the Guardian and Observer Weekend by signing up to receive £1 off the Saturday Guardian and £1 off the Observer for two weekends. Watch our video and get your vouchers Today's best video Tigers play with snowmen at safari park Four Siberian Amur tigers enjoy heavy snow at Longleat in Wiltshire PSV Eindhoven miss three chances in a row from two yards Dutch giants beaten 3-1 by lowly PEC Zwolle Hilary Mantel on adapting her novels for the stage Wolf Hall and Bring Up the Bodies author on RSC collaboration Elk dodges traffic on Moscow motorway Animal dodges rush-hour cars on busy ring road in Russian capital Higher Education Network Research in brief – 24 January 2013 Our weekly round-up aimed at showcasing the latest research across the subject spectrum at UK universities Teacher Network Should I stay or should I go: it's tough to quit a headship after 17 years With fond memories and many achievements, Kenny Frederick is leaving headship for a new challenge. Here, she reflects on her career and asks, is there ever a good time to leave? More from Guardian Professional On Education Most viewed Latest Last 24 hours 1. A-level overhaul could cripple school system, say critics 2. Exeter sex tape: who really misbehaved? 3. University guide 2013: University league table 4. GCSE results set to accelerate plan to turn secondary schools into academies 5. A-levels: Should the traditional two-year course be reinstated? More most viewed Last 24 hours 1. Mary McIntosh obituary 2. Choose the right MBA course 3. Why study science? Parties, prospects and weird facts to unnerve your mates 4. GCSE results set to accelerate plan to turn secondary schools into academies 5. Come forage for winter's hidden harvest – video All today's stories EducationGuardian on Twitter Get the latest news from our education team on Twitter JudyFriedberg: Lovely! Students go foraging for winter's hidden harvest - then cook low-fat meal to suit January detox http://t.co/Qzrvqw6i #education about 3 hours ago JudyFriedberg: A-level choices: which subjects should you pick? Let @louisetickle be your guide http://t.co/MObzuh5l #education about 23 hours, 12 minutes ago GuardianTeach: Got a burning question about teaching applications, interviews or trial lessons? Then join us at 6pm http://t.co/Evs3crd9 #education about 1 week, 1 day ago • Follow our education team on a Twitter list This week's bestsellers 1. Examined Life by Stephen Grosz £11.99 2. What Has Nature Ever Done for Us? by Tony Juniper £7.99 3. Heaven on Earth by Sadakat Kadri £7.99 4. Play it Again by Alan Rusbridger £15.19 5. Steve Biddulph's Raising Girls by Steve Biddulph £10.39 Search the Guardian bookshop Search Bestsellers from our Guardian stores Halogen heaters Halogen heaters for flexible, immediate warmth. Get two for just £44.99 plus p&p. More from Guardian Essentials Ice Treads Ice treads simply fit over your shoe. One pair just £12.99, two pairs £19.99. More from Guardian Essentials Sponsored feature Top stories in this section Top videos Most popular Today in pictures BBC Sports Personality of the Year – in pictures Bradley Wiggins capped his remarkable sporting year by taking home the big prize at the ceremony in London Dinner, dusk and dancing Russians: my best winter shot A glass of wine with a rough sleeper, Santa in trunks, a thousand partying Muscovites … in a My Best Shot special, top photographers pick the image that sums up winter for them Monkey adopts kitten – in pictures Kimon, an eight-year-old pet female long-tailed monkey, treats a kitten as her baby in Bintan Island, Indonesia Hot topics University league tables School league tables A-levels and A-level results Clearing University guide License/buy our content | Privacy policy | Terms & conditions | Advertising guide | Accessibility | A-Z index | Inside the Guardian blog | About us | Work for us | Join our dating site today © 2013 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. Share Tweet this