Home > Opinion > The Debate Over the Death Penalty Hasn't Changed in Why the debate over the death penalty is the same today as it was in the of Capital Punishment in America," Evan J. Mandery, a professor at John impacted the application of the death penalty today and what may change Has the death penalty always been legal in America? Court decision had the practical effect of ending the death penalty in document and that the death penalty was a cruel and unusual punishment. death penalty was unconstitutional. It was not debated. Thereafter, a death penalty are – a suspension of executions in the United States. Why did the court reverse its 1972 decision on the death penalty? since in 1972 the court did not say the death penalty was Georgia meant the end of the death penalty in the United States. just in the sentiment about capital punishment, but as a reaction to responded either by making the death penalty mandatory [for murder and opponent of capital punishment, he said the problem was that it was too death penalty was its arbitrariness. And in 1976, the court said that you can't have [a] mandatory death penalty, and a nonarbitrary death nonarbitrary death penalty law is. And it's, to say the least, a very story of the death penalty, [but also to show] how the Supreme Court death penalty