Fox News - Fair & Balanced Fox News Digital Network Fox News Fox Business uReport Fox News Radio Fox News Latino Fox Nation Fox News Insider * Login Account You're logged in as * Profile * Logout Search Site __________________________________________________ Search Listen to Fox News Radio Live› On Air Now › On Air Personalities › * * Home * Video * Politics * U.S. * Opinion * Entertainment * Tech * Science * Health * Travel * Lifestyle * World * Sports * On Air Previous Slide Next Slide * U.S. Home * Crime * Terrorism * Economy * Immigration * Disasters * Military * Education * Environment * Personal Freedoms * Regions Just or Not, Cost of Death Penalty Is a Killer for State Budgets By Ed Barnes Published March 27, 2010 FoxNews.com Every time a killer is sentenced to die, a school closes. That is the broad assessment of a growing number of studies taking a cold, hard look at how much the death penalty costs in the 35 states that still have it. Forget justice, morality, the possibility of killing an innocent man or any of the traditional arguments that have been part of the public debate over the death penalty. The new one is this: The cost of killing killers is killing us. "There have been studies of costs of the death penalty before, but we have never seen the same reaction that we are seeing now," says Richard C. Dieter of the non-partisan Death Penalty Information Center. "Perhaps it is because governments are looking for ways to cut costs, and this is easier than school closings or layoffs, but it sure has hit a nerve." In the last year, four states — Kansas, Colorado, Montana and Connecticut — have wrestled with the emotional and politically charged issue. In each state there was a major shift toward rejection of the death penalty and narrow defeats for legislation that would have abolished it. In Connecticut, both houses actually voted in favor of a bill that would have banned executions, but the governor vetoed it. Unlike past debates over executions, the current battles are fueled largely by the costs the death penalty imposes on states. The numbers, according to the studies, are staggering. Overall, according to Dieter, the studies have uniformly and conservatively shown that a death-penalty trial costs $1 million more than one in which prosecutors seek life without parole. That expense is being reexamined in the current budget crisis, with some state legislators advocating a moratorium on death-penalty trials until the economy improves. An Urban Institute study of Maryland's experience with the death penalty found that a single death-penalty trial cost $1.9 million more than a non-death-penalty trial. Since 1978, the cost to taxpayers for the five executions the state carried out was $37.2 million dollars — each. Since 1983, taxpayers in New Jersey have paid $253 million more for death penalty trials than they would have paid for trials not seeking execution — but the Garden State has yet to execute a single convict. Of the 197 capital cases tried in New Jersey, there have been 60 death sentences, the report said, and 50 of the those convictions were overturned. There currently are 10 men on the state's death row. A recent Duke University study of North Carolina's death penalty costs found that the state could save $11 million a year by substituting life in prison for the death penalty. An earlier Duke study found that the state spent $2.1 million more on a death penalty case than on one seeking a life sentence. The Tennessee Comptroller of the Currency recently estimated that death penalty trials cost an average of 48 percent more than trials in which prosecutors sought life sentences. It was much the same story in Kansas. A state-sponsored study found that death penalty cases cost 70 percent more than murder trials that didn't seek the death penalty. A Florida study found the state could cut its costs by $51 million simply by eliminating the death penalty. But no state matches the dilemma of California, where almost 700 inmates are sitting on death row and, according to Natasha Minsker, author of a new report by the Northern California chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union, few will ever actually be put to death. In fact, she says, the odds against being executed are so great, murder suspects in California actually seek the death penalty because it is the only way to get a single room in the state's prison system. "Only 1 percent of people sentenced to death in California in the last 30 years have been executed," Minsker said. "The death penalty in California is purely a symbolic sentence." Her study found that the cash-strapped state could immediately save $1 billion by eliminating the death penalty and imposing sentences of life without parole. The alternative, if the cash-strapped state keeps the death penalty: spend $400 million to build a new death-row prison to house the growing number of prisoners. Minsker said just keeping prisoners on death row costs $90,000 more per prisoner per year than regular confinement, because the inmates are housed in single rooms and the prisons are staffed with extra guards. That money alone would cut $63 million from the state budget. But other savings would ripple through every step of the criminal justice system as well, from court costs to subsidized spending for defense attorney and investigation expenses. Will the economic slump and every state's need to cut budgets have an impact? Death penalty opponents say the recession has given their effort a new, non-political reason for abolition that resonates on both sides of the debate. But Professor Paul Cassell, the Ronald N. Boyce Presidential Professor of Criminal Law at the University of Utah and a death penalty expert, says that major changes are not likely to occur soon. "You can make the argument that it is cheaper not to have the death penalty" he said, but that is not what the death penalty is about. The death penalty "provides a sense of justice to the system, is a just punishment for murder and has a deterrent effect on crime," he said. "Besides, the amount of money saved is not that big compared to what the entire justice system spends." "Moreover," he said, "polls show that 70 to 80 percent of people support the death penalty. And that isn't going to change." * * Print * Email * Share * Comments * Recommend * Tweet Share This Article * * * * * View Article Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus. You must login to comment. View Article Advertisement Trending in U.S. * 1 Report: 20 cases of child trafficking investigated in Kentucky in four-month period 2 Debit and credit cards stolen in Target breach reportedly for sale in underground black markets 3 Ukrainian immigrant, 3-year-old son dead in Manhattan building fall 4 Soldier to appeal conviction in gun rights trial 5 Winning bid tops $100G for George Zimmerman flag art See all trends› Bank rates * Mortgage * Home Equity * Autos * CD Rates Loan Type Graph Rate +/- Last Week 30 Y Fixed Graph 4.48% dw 4.49% 15 Y Fixed Graph 3.53% up 3.52% 30 Y Fixed Jumbo Graph 4.60% up 4.57% 5/1 ARM Graph 3.60% up 3.46% 5/1 Jumbo ARM Graph 2.97% up 2.94% Find Personalized Rates Enter Zip Code____________________________________ (BUTTON) Search Loan Type Graph Rate +/- Last Week $30K HELOC Graph 4.84% up 4.78% $50K HELOC Graph 4.58% up 4.45% $30K Loan Graph 6.36% up 6.15% $50K Loan Graph 6.18% up 5.74% $75K Loan Graph 6.16% up 5.69% Find Personalized Rates Enter Zip Code____________________________________ (BUTTON) Search Loan Type Graph Rate +/- Last Week 36 M New Graph 2.67% -- 2.67% 36 M Used Graph 2.90% dw 2.91% 48 M New Graph 2.96% -- 2.96% 48 M Used Graph 2.81% -- 2.81% 60 M New Graph 2.94% -- 2.94% Find Personalized Rates Enter Zip Code____________________________________ (BUTTON) Search Loan Type Graph Yield +/- Last Week 6 month Graph 0.40% -- 0.40% 1 yr Graph 0.66% dw 0.67% 5 yr Graph 1.34% -- 1.34% Compare Rates Enter Zip Code____________________________________ 1-year CD * 1-year CD * 6-month CD * 3-month CD * 5-year CD * 1-year jumbo CD * Money Market Account * Jumbo MMA (BUTTON) Search Advertisement Also on the web * Why Did BuzzFeed & Co. Target Justine Sacco for Online Assassination Andrew Sullivan: Phil Robertson Suspension 'Preposterous,' 'Unfair' 'Breitbart News Sunday' on SXM 125: Christmas Show and the Fed at 100 Vatican Hires Large American Consultancy Firm to Advise on Media Operations Scott Rasmussen Slams WaPo for Calling Congressional Critics ‘Haters’ * Save on Last Minute Hotel Rooms -- Savings Experiment Save on Gifts That Keep on Giving -- Savings Experiment Pinpoint What You Were Born To Do Consumer Spending Brightens Economic Outlook Money Minute: Backlash Hurts Target Sales; Apple Scores Big China Deal * At least 44 dead, dozens wounded in bombardment of Aleppo Unexpected Holiday Reunion: Carlos Santana Greets Long-Lost Band Member, Now Homeless Winter Brings Snow, Ice, Rain, Record Temps In North America Bad Joke Or Freudian Slip? Unhappy Over The Seahawks' Loss To The Cardinals, Politician Calls Arizona 'Racist Wasteland' Huge icestorm causes chaos in Toronto, eastern Canada Sections * Home * Video * Politics * U.S. * Opinion * Entertainment * Tech * Science * Health * Travel * Lifestyle * World * Sports * Weather Shows * A Healthy You & Carol Alt * America's News HQ * America's Newsroom * Cavuto * Fox Files * Fox News Sunday * Fox & Friends First * Fox & Friends * Fox & Friends Weekend * Geraldo at Large * Greta * Hannity * Happening Now * Huckabee * Justice with Judge Jeanine * Media Buzz * Red Eye w/ Gutfeld * Shepard Smith Reporting * Special Report * Specials * The Cost of Freedom * The Five * The Journal Editorial Report * The Kelly File * The O' Reilly Factor * The Real Story * War Stories Tools * Live Video * Trending * uReport * Newsletters * Alerts * Blogs * Mobile * Podcasts * Radio * Fox News Store * Apps & Downloads About * Careers * College Students * Fox Around the World * Advertise With Us * Terms of Use * Privacy Policy * Ad Choices * Contact Us * Email Newsroom * FAQ * Media Relations Follow * Facebook * Twitter * Google+ * LinkedIn * RSS * Newsletters * Fox News * This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. ©2013 FOX News Network, LLC. All rights reserved. All market data delayed 20 minutes.