10 *	Share
  10 to	the
   8 Share	on
   7 switch	to
   6 *	(BUTTON)
   6 of	the
   5 The	Guardian
   5 edition	*
   5 the	virus
   4 *	switch
   4 [	]
   4 in	the
   4 older	people
   3 *	Guardian
   3 +	switch
   3 Facebook	*
   3 Global	development
   3 International	edition
   3 Search	jobs
   3 Twitter	*
   3 app	*
   3 edition	+
   3 he	said.
   3 it	was
   3 people	in
   3 the	UK
   3 the	population
   3 us	+
   2 *	Africa
   2 *	Americas
   2 *	Asia
   2 *	Australia
   2 *	Coronavirus
   2 *	Culture
   2 *	Digital
   2 *	Europe
   2 *	Global
   2 *	Holidays
   2 *	Inequality
   2 *	Lifestyle
   2 *	Middle
   2 *	News
   2 *	Opinion
   2 *	Search
   2 *	Sport
   2 *	The
   2 *	US
   2 *	World
   2 +	All
   2 +	Football
   2 2	months
   2 Africa	*
   2 Americas	*
   2 Archive	*
   2 Asia	*
   2 Australia	*
   2 Australia	edition
   2 Available	for
   2 Back	to
   2 Contribute	Subscribe
   2 Culture	*
   2 Digital	Archive
   2 East	*
   2 Europe	*
   2 Football	+
   2 Guardian	Available
   2 Guardian	Puzzles
   2 Holidays	*
   2 Inequality	*
   2 Middle	East
   2 News	*
   2 Oct	2020
   2 Opinion	*
   2 Puzzles	app
   2 Share	via
   2 Sheffield	Hallam
   2 Sport	*
   2 Support	The
   2 The	authors
   2 This	article
   2 UK	edition
   2 US	*
   2 US	edition
   2 World	*
   2 ______________________________________________________________	*
   2 a	professor
   2 allowed	to
   2 and	healthy
   2 and	others
   2 argue	that
   2 article	is
   2 at	Sheffield
   2 at	a
   2 be	allowed
   2 by	readers
   2 caused	by
   2 damage	caused
   2 everyone,	funded
   2 for	everyone,
   2 funded	by
   2 groups	in
   2 healthy	people
   2 herd	immunity
   2 is	more
   2 jobs	*
   2 months	old
   2 more	than
   2 news	+
   2 on	Facebook
   2 on	Twitter
   2 people	*
   2 policy	+
   2 professor	of
   2 readers	Contribute
   2 said	the
   2 should	be
   2 sick	and
   2 students	at
   2 than	2
   2 the	Australia
   2 the	US
   2 the	declaration
   2 the	declaration,
   2 to	resume
   2 via	Email
   2 you	can
   2 young	and
   1 –	Sunetra
   1 –	argue
   1 –	latest
   1 ‘grotesque’	*
   1 “After	pointing
   1 “If	you’re
   1 “Stating	that
   1 “culling	the
   1 “devastating	effects”
   1 “grotesque”	plan
   1 “herd	immunity”,
   1 “immediately	be
   1 “long	Covid”
   1 “merely	dragged
   1 “the	Great
   1 “unfeasible”,	while
   1 #publisher	alternate
   1 &	Media
   1 &	conditions
   1 &	corrections
   1 &	design
   1 &	fitness
   1 &	garden
   1 &	marketing
   1 &	radio
   1 &	replies
   1 &	sex
   1 (BUTTON)	Close
   1 (BUTTON)	Culture
   1 (BUTTON)	International
   1 (BUTTON)	Lifestyle
   1 (BUTTON)	More
   1 (BUTTON)	News
   1 (BUTTON)	Opinion
   1 (BUTTON)	Search
   1 (BUTTON)	Sport
   1 *	Account
   1 *	Billing
   1 *	Comments
   1 *	Crosswords
   1 *	Disability
   1 *	Emails
   1 *	Facebook
   1 *	Health
   1 *	Help
   1 *	Infectious
   1 *	Inside
   1 *	Make
   1 *	Medical
   1 *	Newsletters
   1 *	Older
   1 *	Pictures
   1 *	Podcasts
   1 *	Profile
   1 *	Reuse
   1 *	See
   1 *	Settings
   1 *	Sign
   1 *	Subscribe
   1 *	Today's
   1 *	Twitter
   1 *	Video
   1 *	Young
   1 *	news
   1 +	Advertise
   1 +	Art
   1 +	Books
   1 +	Business
   1 +	Cartoons
   1 +	Classical
   1 +	Columnists
   1 +	Complaints
   1 +	Contact
   1 +	Cookie
   1 +	Coronavirus
   1 +	Cricket
   1 +	Cycling
   1 +	Digital
   1 +	Environment
   1 +	F1
   1 +	Facebook
   1 +	Family
   1 +	Fashion
   1 +	Film
   1 +	Food
   1 +	Games
   1 +	Global
   1 +	Golf
   1 +	Health
   1 +	Help
   1 +	Home
   1 +	Letters
   1 +	Love
   1 +	Men
   1 +	Money
   1 +	Music
   1 +	Newsletters
   1 +	Obituaries
   1 +	Opinion
   1 +	Privacy
   1 +	Recipes
   1 +	Rugby
   1 +	Science
   1 +	Search
   1 +	SecureDrop
   1 +	Stage
   1 +	TV
   1 +	Tech
   1 +	Tennis
   1 +	Terms
   1 +	The
   1 +	Travel
   1 +	Twitter
   1 +	UK
   1 +	US
   1 +	Women
   1 +	Work
   1 +	World
   1 -	Back
   1 04.37	BST
   1 19.16	BST
   1 2020	04.37
   1 2020	19.16
   1 2020	Guardian
   1 2CDisability%2CWorld+news%2CSociety%2CMedical+research]	
   1 2CHealth%2CInfectious+diseases%2CScience%2CYoung+people%2COlder+people%	2CDisability%2CWorld+news%2CSociety%2CMedical+research]
   1 6	Oct
   1 7	Oct
   1 75,	you
   1 @iansample	Tue
   1 Account	overview
   1 Advertise	with
   1 All	rights
   1 All	topics
   1 All	writers
   1 An	international
   1 Anglia	and
   1 Another	concern,
   1 Art	&
   1 BST	*
   1 BST	Last
   1 Barrington	declaration”,
   1 Bhattacharya,	of
   1 Billing	*
   1 Books	+
   1 Business	+
   1 Cartoons	+
   1 Classical	+
   1 Close	[p?c1=2&c2=6035250&cv=2.0&cj=1&cs_ucfr=0&gdpr=0&comscorekw=Coronavirus%
   1 Columnists	+
   1 Comments	&
   1 Complaints	&
   1 Contact	us
   1 Contribute	Search
   1 Cookie	policy
   1 Coronavirus	*
   1 Coronavirus	+
   1 Coronavirus	This
   1 Coronavirus	–
   1 Covid	becomes
   1 Covid	herd
   1 Covid-19	lockdowns
   1 Covid-19,	he
   1 Covid:	the
   1 Covid”	disorders
   1 Cricket	+
   1 Critics	describe
   1 Crosswords	*
   1 Culture	+
   1 Cycling	+
   1 Danny	Lawson/PA
   1 David	Livermore,
   1 Described	as
   1 Digital	newspaper
   1 Disability	*
   1 East	Anglia
   1 Efforts	to
   1 Email	*
   1 Email	Self-isolating
   1 Emails	&
   1 Environment	+
   1 F1	+
   1 Facebook	+
   1 Family	+
   1 Fashion	+
   1 Film	+
   1 Food	+
   1 Games	+
   1 Golf	+
   1 Gonsalves,	an
   1 Great	Barrington
   1 Greenhalgh,	also
   1 Gregg	Gonsalves,
   1 Guardian	*
   1 Guardian	-
   1 Guardian	News
   1 Guardian	Weekly
   1 Guardian	app
   1 Guardian	view
   1 Gupta	and
   1 Gupta,	of
   1 Hallam	University
   1 Hallam	University,
   1 Hanage	and
   1 Hanage,	a
   1 Harvard	University
   1 Harvard,	said
   1 Health	&
   1 Health	*
   1 Help	+
   1 Help	______________________________________________________________
   1 Home	&
   1 House	has
   1 IFRAME:	https://www.theguardian.com/email/form/footer/today-uk
   1 Ian	Sample
   1 In	a
   1 In	one
   1 Infectious	diseases
   1 Inside	the
   1 It’s	grotesque.”
   1 Jay	Bhattacharya,
   1 Kulldorff,	of
   1 Last	modified
   1 Last	month,
   1 Lawson/PA	An
   1 Letters	*
   1 Lifestyle	+
   1 Lifestyle	IFRAME:
   1 Lifestyle	[
   1 Limited	or
   1 LinkedIn	*
   1 Livermore,	a
   1 Long	Covid:
   1 Love	&
   1 Make	a
   1 Martin	Kulldorff,
   1 Massachusetts	town
   1 Media	Limited
   1 Medical	research
   1 Men	+
   1 Messenger	*
   1 Money	____________________
   1 More	*
   1 More	Coronavirus
   1 Most	popular
   1 Music	+
   1 My	account
   1 News	&
   1 News	+
   1 Newsletters	*
   1 Newsletters	+
   1 Obituaries	*
   1 Observer	*
   1 Older	people
   1 One	critic
   1 Opinion	+
   1 Opinion	videos
   1 Oxford	University,
   1 Oxford,	said
   1 Photograph:	Danny
   1 Pictures	*
   1 Pinterest	*
   1 Podcasts	*
   1 Privacy	policy
   1 Prof	Gupta
   1 Prof	Trish
   1 Profile	*
   1 Read	more
   1 Recipes	+
   1 Reuse	this
   1 Rugby	union
   1 Sample	Science
   1 Science	+
   1 Science	editor
   1 Scientists	call
   1 Search	UK
   1 Search	[
   1 Search	with
   1 SecureDrop	+
   1 See	all
   1 Self-isolating	students
   1 Settings	*
   1 Show	More
   1 Sign	in
   1 Sign	out
   1 Skip	to
   1 Sport	+
   1 Stage	*
   1 Stanford	University,
   1 Subscribe	*
   1 Subscribe	Back
   1 Subscribe	Contribute
   1 Sunetra	Gupta,
   1 TV	&
   1 Tech	+
   1 Tennis	+
   1 Terms	&
   1 The	Observer
   1 The	proposal,
   1 The	scientists
   1 Today's	paper
   1 Topics	*
   1 Travel	+
   1 Trish	Greenhalgh,
   1 Tue	6
   1 Twitter	+
   1 Twitter	thread
   1 UK	jobs
   1 UK	news
   1 UK	offered
   1 US	sports
   1 University	[
   1 University	of
   1 University	–
   1 University,	Jay
   1 University,	and
   1 University,	pictured,
   1 University,	said
   1 Video	*
   1 Wed	7
   1 Weekly	*
   1 What	term
   1 WhatsApp	*
   1 While	many
   1 White	House
   1 William	Hanage,
   1 With	nearly
   1 Women	+
   1 Work	by
   1 Work	for
   1 World	news
   1 Yale	University,
   1 Young	people
   1 [p?c1=2&c2=6035250&cv=2.0&cj=1&cs_ucfr=0&gdpr=0&comscorekw=Coronavirus%	2CHealth%2CInfectious+diseases%2CScience%2CYoung+people%2COlder+people%
   1 ]	*
   1 ]	My
   1 ]	Show
   1 ]	The
   1 ____________________	What
   1 a	Twitter
   1 a	contribution
   1 a	culling
   1 a	hotly
   1 a	month
   1 a	proposal
   1 a	signatory
   1 a	time
   1 a	time.
   1 about	“culling
   1 accommodation	for
   1 account	*
   1 achieving	“herd
   1 added,	was
   1 added.	Last
   1 advice.	In
   1 affected	young
   1 affiliated	companies.
   1 after	the
   1 all	our
   1 allow	young
   1 already	affected
   1 also	at
   1 alternate	Skip
   1 among	young
   1 amounted	to
   1 an	apparently
   1 an	entire
   1 an	epidemiologist
   1 an	uncontrolled
   1 and	Martin
   1 and	a
   1 and	allow
   1 and	climbs
   1 and	disabled
   1 and	disabled.
   1 and	harming
   1 and	her
   1 and	older
   1 and	other
   1 and	restrictions
   1 and	vaccines
   1 answer	is
   1 apparently	ongoing
   1 approaches	to
   1 archive	+
   1 are	found,
   1 are	having
   1 are	trying
   1 argued	that
   1 argues	for
   1 as	little
   1 as	normal”.
   1 as	possible,”
   1 as	self-isolating
   1 as	‘grotesque’
   1 as	“the
   1 at	Harvard,
   1 at	Oxford,
   1 at	Yale
   1 at	risk
   1 at	the
   1 attacking	the
   1 authors	conceded
   1 authors	of
   1 back	radically
   1 be	attacking
   1 be	protected
   1 be	shielded
   1 bearing	the
   1 becomes	more
   1 between	scientists
   1 burden.	While
   1 but	signed
   1 but	suggested
   1 by	Hanage
   1 by	Prof
   1 by	disrupting
   1 by	it,”
   1 by	many
   1 by	testing
   1 by	the
   1 by	three
   1 call	for
   1 called	on
   1 can	choose
   1 can	keep
   1 care	and
   1 care	homes
   1 carers	were
   1 choose	to
   1 climbs	exponentially
   1 cohort	of
   1 colleagues	argued
   1 community,	but
   1 companies.	All
   1 conceded	it
   1 concern,	he
   1 conditions	+
   1 conflicting	advice.
   1 content	Most
   1 content	The
   1 contested	debate
   1 contribution	*
   1 coronavirus	coverage
   1 coronavirus	strategies
   1 corrections	+
   1 correctly,	the
   1 could	leave
   1 could	shield
   1 coverage	Ian
   1 crisis.	One
   1 critic	said
   1 culling	of
   1 current	edition:
   1 cut	off
   1 damage	Read
   1 danger	should
   1 debate	between
   1 declaration	seemed
   1 declaration	–
   1 declaration,	Gregg
   1 declaration,	said
   1 declaration”,	after
   1 describe	proposal
   1 design	+
   1 development	(BUTTON)
   1 development	*
   1 development	+
   1 different	approaches
   1 direct	damage
   1 disabled	and
   1 disabled	people.
   1 disabled.	It’s
   1 diseases	*
   1 disorders	that
   1 disrupting	routine
   1 do	you
   1 dragged	matters
   1 drawn	up
   1 drawn	up,
   1 edition	current
   1 edition:	International
   1 editor	@iansample
   1 effects”	on
   1 either	the
   1 enough	of
   1 entire	cohort
   1 epidemiologist	at
   1 epidemiology	at
   1 evidence	of
   1 exponentially	from
   1 fitness	+
   1 flu	for
   1 for	Covid
   1 for	Covid-19,
   1 for	a
   1 for	letting
   1 for	people
   1 for	us
   1 for	young
   1 found,	the
   1 from	open
   1 from	there,
   1 garden	+
   1 go	out
   1 good	salaries
   1 google	*
   1 governments	are
   1 governments	to
   1 greatest	burden.
   1 grotesque.”	Topics
   1 group	of
   1 half	of
   1 harder	to
   1 harming	mental
   1 has	an
   1 has	called
   1 have	already
   1 having	some
   1 having	“devastating
   1 he	added,
   1 he	added.
   1 he	said
   1 headed	by
   1 health	by
   1 health	risk
   1 health,	with
   1 heart	damage
   1 her	colleagues
   1 herd	of
   1 home	Support
   1 homes	might
   1 homes	or
   1 hope	of
   1 hotly	contested
   1 how	likely
   1 https://www.theguardian.com/email/form/footer/today-uk	+
   1 idea	of
   1 if	carers
   1 illustrate	how
   1 immunity	strategies
   1 immunity	strategy
   1 immunity”,	where
   1 in	[
   1 in	a
   1 in	care
   1 in	either
   1 in	low-risk
   1 in	their
   1 including	the
   1 increase	the
   1 indirect	damage
   1 individuals	could
   1 infection.	With
   1 infections	low
   1 international	group
   1 interventions	were
   1 is	resistant
   1 is	to
   1 is,”	he
   1 isolate	vulnerable,
   1 issues,	including
   1 it,”	he
   1 its	affiliated
   1 jobs	Sign
   1 jobs	Support
   1 keep	infections
   1 keep	the
   1 large	number
   1 latest	round
   1 latest	updates
   1 least	danger
   1 leave	many
   1 lethal	than
   1 letter,	Prof
   1 letting	the
   1 life	as
   1 life	while
   1 life.	Photograph:
   1 likely	that
   1 lingering	heart
   1 little	as
   1 live	in
   1 lockdowns	and
   1 lockdowns,	a
   1 long-term	medical
   1 low	“merely
   1 low-risk	groups
   1 main	content
   1 many	governments
   1 many	more,
   1 many	with
   1 marketing	*
   1 marks	the
   1 mass,	ongoing
   1 matters	out”,
   1 meaning	that
   1 medical	issues,
   1 medical	microbiology
   1 mental	health,
   1 microbiology	at
   1 mid-30s	and
   1 might	be
   1 modified	on
   1 month	at
   1 month,	two
   1 more	Work
   1 more	lethal
   1 more,	argues
   1 most	vulnerable.
   1 nearly	half
   1 necessary	to
   1 need	protecting.
   1 neighbouring	accommodation
   1 new	treatments
   1 news	*
   1 newspaper	archive
   1 nobody	was
   1 normal	life
   1 normal	life.
   1 normal”.	David
   1 not	practical
   1 number	of
   1 of	East
   1 of	Harvard
   1 of	Oxford
   1 of	Stanford
   1 of	achieving
   1 of	epidemiology
   1 of	infection.
   1 of	lingering
   1 of	mass,
   1 of	medical
   1 of	older
   1 of	places
   1 of	scientists
   1 of	sick
   1 of	vulnerable
   1 off	an
   1 offered	conflicting
   1 old	Critics
   1 old	Scientists
   1 on	LinkedIn
   1 on	Messenger
   1 on	Pinterest
   1 on	Wed
   1 on	WhatsApp
   1 on	governments
   1 on	public
   1 one	open
   1 ongoing	lockdowns,
   1 ongoing	outbreak
   1 open	letter,
   1 open	society.
   1 or	its
   1 or	neighbouring
   1 other	interventions
   1 other,	headed
   1 others	at
   1 others	suggests
   1 our	coronavirus
   1 out	Search
   1 out	as
   1 out	of
   1 out,	correctly,
   1 outbreak	among
   1 outbreak	should
   1 out”,	he
   1 overturn	their
   1 overview	*
   1 paid	good
   1 pandemic,	they
   1 pandemic.	Described
   1 paper	*
   1 people	and
   1 people	as
   1 people	could
   1 people	from
   1 people	to
   1 people,	such
   1 people.	In
   1 people.	The
   1 pictured,	should
   1 places	by
   1 plan	amounted
   1 plan	marks
   1 pointing	out,
   1 popular	*
   1 population	having
   1 population	is
   1 population	would
   1 possible,”	he
   1 practical	to
   1 proposal	that
   1 proposal	to
   1 proposal,	drawn
   1 protect	the
   1 protected	if
   1 protecting	the
   1 protecting.	“Stating
   1 public	health
   1 quell	the
   1 radically	different
   1 radio	+
   1 rates	of
   1 reduce	rates
   1 replies	______________________________________________________________
   1 research	*
   1 researchers	but
   1 reserved.	(BUTTON)
   1 resistant	to
   1 respond	that
   1 responding	to
   1 restrictions	are
   1 resume	life
   1 resume	normal
   1 return	to
   1 rights	reserved.
   1 risk	for
   1 risk	should
   1 round	in
   1 routine	care
   1 said	herd
   1 said	it
   1 said	older
   1 said	shutdowns
   1 said.	Another
   1 said.	Efforts
   1 said.	Long
   1 salaries	to
   1 scientific	groups
   1 scientists	argue
   1 scientists	has
   1 scientists	who
   1 search?	(BUTTON)
   1 seemed	to
   1 self-isolating	students
   1 sex	+
   1 shield	themselves.
   1 shielded	while
   1 should	illustrate
   1 should	“immediately
   1 shutdowns	and
   1 signatory	of
   1 signed	by
   1 society.	William
   1 some	underlying
   1 sports	*
   1 spread	in
   1 strategies	and
   1 strategies	were
   1 strategy	for
   1 such	as
   1 suggested	individuals
   1 suggesting.	“After
   1 suggests	Covid
   1 suppress	the
   1 suppressing	the
   1 swathes	of
   1 term	do
   1 testing	at
   1 than	flu
   1 that	Covid-19
   1 that	an
   1 that	have
   1 that	is,”
   1 that	nobody
   1 that	older
   1 that	suppressing
   1 that	swathes
   1 that	the
   1 that	you
   1 that	young
   1 the	Guardian
   1 the	International
   1 the	Massachusetts
   1 the	University
   1 the	White
   1 the	answer
   1 the	community,
   1 the	crisis.
   1 the	direct
   1 the	evidence
   1 the	greatest
   1 the	herd
   1 the	homes
   1 the	hope
   1 the	idea
   1 the	indirect
   1 the	large
   1 the	latest
   1 the	least
   1 the	most
   1 the	other,
   1 the	pandemic,
   1 the	pandemic.
   1 the	plan
   1 the	sick
   1 the	trio
   1 the	underprivileged
   1 the	“grotesque”
   1 the	“long
   1 their	coronavirus
   1 their	mid-30s
   1 themselves.	“If
   1 there,	meaning
   1 they	respond
   1 this	content
   1 those	in
   1 thread	responding
   1 three	researchers
   1 time	when
   1 time.	The
   1 to	a
   1 to	be
   1 to	cut
   1 to	go
   1 to	home
   1 to	increase
   1 to	isolate
   1 to	keep
   1 to	live
   1 to	main
   1 to	normal
   1 to	overturn
   1 to	protect
   1 to	quell
   1 to	reduce
   1 to	return
   1 to	search?
   1 to	suppress
   1 to	top
   1 top	©
   1 topics	+
   1 town	where
   1 treatments	and
   1 trio	write
   1 trying	to
   1 two	scientific
   1 uncontrolled	outbreak
   1 underlying	health
   1 underprivileged	bearing
   1 union	+
   1 until	new
   1 up	by
   1 up,	the
   1 updates	*
   1 vaccines	are
   1 videos	+
   1 view	+
   1 virus	out
   1 virus	spread
   1 virus	to
   1 virus	until
   1 virus	was
   1 vulnerable	people
   1 vulnerable,	disabled
   1 vulnerable.	The
   1 want	to
   1 was	drawn
   1 was	harder
   1 was	not
   1 was	suggesting.
   1 was	that
   1 was	“unfeasible”,
   1 were	about
   1 were	necessary
   1 were	paid
   1 when	the
   1 where	enough
   1 where	it
   1 while	protecting
   1 while	the
   1 while	those
   1 who	back
   1 with	google
   1 with	long-term
   1 with	the
   1 with	us
   1 would	need
   1 write	that
   1 writers	+
   1 you	want
   1 young	This
   1 young	people,
   1 young	people.
   1 you’re	75,
   1 ©	2020